top
Palestine
Palestine
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

The historical mistreatment of Jews under Arab/Muslim rule

by KL
Time and again it is alleged that Jews had it good under Arab/Muslim rule -- until the establishment of Israel. This is pure fiction.
Jews living in Arab/Moslem lands were officially second class citizens, century after century, having to yield the sidewalk to Muslims, unable to testify in court (which makes it difficult to defend yourself from false accusations), often not allowed to build/repair synagogues (which in any case couldn't be as grand as the neighboring mosques) and subject to pogroms.

Albert Memmi, a Tunisian-born author and political theorist, writes: "Never, except for two or three eras with very clear boundaries in time, such as the Andalusian period ...have the Jews lived in the Arab countries otherwise than as a diminished people in an exposed position, periodically overcome and massacred."

For example, decrees ordering the destruction of synagogues were enacted in Egypt & Syria (1014, 1293, 1301), Iraq (854, 1344) and Yemen (1676). Forced conversions (or death) in Morocco (1275, 1465, 1790) and Baghdad (1333, 1344). Even massacres (5000 Jews in Grenada in 1066, all but 11 Jews in Fez in 1465), Libya (1785), Algiers (1805, 1815, 1830) and Morocco (1864 and 1880).


http://www.nitle.org/arabworld/texts.php?module_id=6&reading_id=54

| As the nineteenth century began... Jews had to bear the burden of social isolation, inferiority, and general opprobrium. Over the preceding four centuries, they had become increasingly confined into overcrowded ghetto-like quarters, which were called by a variety of names throughout the Muslim world (for example, Mellah, Harat al-Yahud, and Mahallat al-Yahud ). European travelers of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries were unanimous in their reports of the overall debasement of the Jews living in the Islamic lands. The Italian Jewish poet and traveler Samuel Romanelli, who spent four years among his coreligionists in Morocco in the late eighteenth century, described them as "oppressed, miserable creatures, having neither the mouth to answer an Arab, nor the cheek to raise their head." 3 And the Englishman Edward William Lane, who lived in Cairo during the 1820s and 1830s and was a keen and sympathetic observer of native life, depicted the Jews of Egypt as being "held in the utmost contempt and abhorrence by Muslims in general." 4 He also noted that the condition of the Jewish lower class was wretched and that many in this group depended on alms. 5

Even in the Holy Land, the Jewish homeland, the fate of the Jews under foreign Arab/Muslim rulers was no better:

The Jerusalem Jews were bitterly and mercilessly persecuted during the 17th century reign of an Arab ruler Ibn Barouk who bought the rule from Murad IV. In 1660 the entire Jewish community was massacred by Arabs with only one survivor.

Little is known by Arabs as to why Ahmad Basha El-Jazzar (The Butcher) held this name, his sadistic wanton exploits became legend during the 1800s, who was known to travel accompanied by an executioner. When The Butcher encountered a subject who was adjudged to be misbehaving, "The criminal bowed his neck, the executioner struck, and the head fell" (DeHass). Hayim Farhi, the only Jew who has risen to power in the area was imprisoned by The Butcher, cutting off his nose, ear, and gouging out his eye. The Jews were at the bottom of the heap of peoples in status who had to pay to pray on the Wailing Wall, protection money was always collected against destruction and vandalism of the Jewish burial grounds, and to prevent molestation of Jewish travelers.

In the 1830s havoc was created during the Egyptian reign of Palestine, and the Jews were persecuted brutally throughout the country. In 1834 the inhabitants of Eastern Palestine crossed the Jordan River to join natives of Nablus, Hebron, and Bethlehem, 40,000 of them rushed on Jerusalem and looted the city for 5 days where the Jews had their homes sacked and their women raped. (DeHass, History, vol V, p.393).

The Jewish story in Palestine was like the story of a rape victim, blamed for being there at the time. Between 1848 - 1878 scores of incidents involving anti-Jewish violence, persecution, and extortions filled page after page of documented reports from the British Consulate in Jerusalem.

Throughout the 19th century Jews were victims of mass hunger and of Arab attacks. The 1929 Arab riots resulted in the rape and massacre of most of Hebron's Jewish community.

All this long before 1948.
by John Veldhuis
And if all this is true you believe this legitimizes the terrorist behaviour of the state of Israel in the Palestinian territories?

Fight terrorism,
boycott Israel.
by KL
There are plenty of articles here in which your false allegations are already discussed.

These articles may be of interest to you:

Palestinian Arabs give high ratings to Israeli Democracy and Human Rights
http://www.indybay.org/news/2003/07/1624443.php

The Land of Israel in the 19th century
http://www.indybay.org/news/2003/06/1623475.php

The topic here is the historic mistreatment of Jews in Arab/Muslim countries, as distinctly different from the propaganda repeatedly seen that it was the establishment of Israel that caused Arab antisemitism.

Fight hate.
by teacake
Ever consider that you guys are the hateful ones and it is you passing around lies and propaganda? Sorry that facts and reality are too much for you to digest.
by Prof. Benny Morris
If you contest any of the facts cited in the Article, please tell us on what grounds you do so. In other words, a vacuous charge that someone is lying, without being able to show any lies, is juvenile.


Palestinian leaders and preachers, guided by history and religion, have traditionally seen the Jews as an inferior race whose proper place was as an abased minority in a Muslim polity; and the present situation, with an Arab minority under Jewish rule, is regarded as a perversion of nature and divine will.

http://www.tnr.com/docprint.mhtml?i=20030421&s=morris042103
by Zaihas
Reading at the article makes me feel that the author is trying to exaggerate small points in and attempt to divert attention from the bigger and more ugly facts of Jewish life in European Christian countries, which were saddening until quite recently. Remember the Holocaust?
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$75.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network