top
Anti-War
Anti-War
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

March/Meeting Demanding Senate Hearing on 9-11

by Carol Brouillet (cbrouillet [at] igc.org)
First person account of march/meeting to demand Senate Inquiry of 9-11

Demanding a Congressional Inquiry of 9-11


On Tuesday, January 8th, 2002, at eleven o'clock people began to gather at Justin Herman Plaza. As organizer, I baked bread and cookies that morning, figuring folks would be hungry (I always bring food to my weekly peace demos in Palo Alto- people can't resist the cookies and dialogue happens…) Supporters came from all over the Bay Area, as well as Japan, there were three guitarists and a couple of big banners including Veteran's for Peace- "War War What is it good for? Absolutely nothing." And- "One People, One Earth, One Love" a quote from Alice Walker with an image of the Earth with a heart over it surrounded by a group of people holding hands on the other side "One Air, One Water, One Hope Respect all Life" with an image of 3 interconnected circles (which we made for the first, big, national, DC anti-war demo on September 29th). The atmosphere was very friendly with much sharing of information. Bill Moyer, author of Doing Democracy, who has mapped out the eight stages of social movements and helped empower activists for forty years came, just five minutes after I passed out his useful diagrams and pointed out where we were in the stages of social movements (going from one to two- critical problem exists- few people aware- showing failure of existing institutions).


The media swooped down in a pack, two or three television stations (but I don't think any was aired publicly) and three radio journalists(KGO, KPFA, Chinese), and at least one newspaper reporter. The march was colorful and lively, although somewhat small, about thirty or so people, so we kept to the sidewalk with a police escort. (There probably would have been more people, if we hadn't been "competing" with a major event- the Deputy General of the WTO was having a debate with activists across town at the same time. And it is hard to organize when you're out of the country without access to a computer, I did the best I could in four days and three kids).



The 9-11 disaster has been used to justify a "War on Terrorism" which endangers the lives and liberties of millions of people everywhere. The U.S. bombing of Afghanistan has killed thousands of civilians; millions of Afghans have been displaced and face starvation this winter. The administration has condoned massive Israeli assaults on Palestine, and threatens to attack Iraq, Lebanon, Somalia, and other countries. Recent legislation is an attack on constitutionally guaranteed civil liberties, especially those of immigrants and people of color. The laws are mirrored in other countries which are outlawing dissent and increasing political repression. The administration has institutionalized racial profiling and is secretly rounding up thousands of Arab Americans and other people of Middle Eastern background. At the same time, it is giving billions to the military, offering huge bailouts and tax incentives to corporations and the wealthy, while ignoring the hundreds of thousands of laid off workers, and cutting social services. This appears to be part of a long-range strategy to turn the clock back on the hard earned gains of the civil rights', women's', and environmental movements, to consolidate U.S. global domination, and to serve the interests of transnational corporations.



At the plaza in front of Senator Feinstein's office the march turned into a party/gathering/leafletting/networking opportunity. The nine person delegation escorted by police, presented identification, got our security clearances and went up to see Senator Feinstein's staff. Senator Boxer's staff also joined the meeting at the last minute.


The delegation spoke on many issues and raised many questions from "Why weren't the hijacked planes intercepted?" to "How can the U.S. declare a 'War on Terrorism' when terrorism has been the keystone of U.S. foreign policy for decades and we continue to fund, train, and arm terrorists?"


Here is the synopsis-



Kevin Danaher Public Education Director of Global Exchange who has written or edited many books examining US foreign policy and the global economy including- Democratizing the Global Economy: The Battle Against the World Bank and the IMF : Globalize This!: The Battle Against the World Trade Organization, and Corporations Are Gonna Get Your Momma: Globalization and the Downsizing of the American Dream, came up with the idea of the Inquiry. He explained how when he is traveling and speaking with many people the questions keep coming up, and people want to know, deserve to know the truth. His wife and daughter had also recently traveled to Afghanistan and he spoke of the plight of the Afghans. He also touched on the larger picture, the pattern of events, the global system, the lost opportunity when the U.S. with all the world feeling sympathetically towards us, chose to violate international law, act unilaterally and bomb.


Riva Enteen- Vice president of the National Lawyers Guild, had compiled a history of the dark times when this country has ignored, violated due process and civil rights. She spoke about how the situation has deteriorated so badly, so quickly. She also questioned whether the victims of the World Trade Center were being given "hush money" so that they could not sue whoever was criminally responsible for the attack.


Carmen Hartono- Women's International Peace Imperative addressed racial profiling, and the stereotyping that distresses her, and her husband. (She is from El Savador and her husband is from Indonesia), She was also deeply concerned about what is happening in Palestine.


Ed Rippy- East Bay Peace Action, talked about the CIA/drug/military connections and the U.S.'s history and current relationship with various terrorists and intelligence agencies, and their links to drug smuggling and money laundering. Ed also reminded us that government's lose their legitimacy if they are not serving the public interest.


Susie Whitlock - Organizing Mills, spoke about the Bush/Bin Laden financial ties and Unocal's oil negotiations in Afghanistan. The recent appointment of the Unocal Advisor to be the representative of the U.S. to the interim government suggests that oil is one of the reasons the U.S. is in Afghanistan.


Cecile Pineda - East Bay Coalition Against the War, spoke very briefly about how the internet has changed the way people communicate. The truth is bound to come out.


Denny Riley - Veteran's for Peace, told his truth. He had witnessed how the government, particularly the military, lies. He had been on missions, chosen targets. Bombs kill civilians. In Vietnam 2 million people were killed; the memorial to them depicts, not soldiers, but civilians because that is primarily who gets killed.


I compiled the key articles to all of the following questions, as well as additional excellent pieces which had not been posted on the internet. I mentioned the online petition which echoed our demands which I had learned of only the night before (http://www.petitiononline.com/11601TFS/petition.html although I accidentally left my hard copy at home).


I couldn't resist asking why Senator Feinstein, and most other Senators were going along with President Bush, without raising any questions. I wondered if they were afraid or whether they really believed what he said.

I probably went too far and was told that Senator Feinstein "believed in Bush" and that the Senator and I have different worldviews…


These are some of the questions that we, the people, demand to be raised and answered publicly-


Who created, trained and funded the Al Qaeda Network?

What is the relationship between Bin Laden, his family and the Bush family and the Carlyle Group?

Why were no fighter planes dispatched to intercept the four hijacked planes on September 11h , in violation of standard procedures?

Who actually was in control of the "hijacked planes"?

What is the U.S. relationship with Pakistan, and especially with its intelligence service, the ISI?

Why did the then director of the ISI have $100,000 transferred to the man whom the FBI now calls the ringleader of the Sept. 11th attacks, and why does the U.S. not pursue this question?

Did the CIA have foreknowledge of the attack, who tried to profit with put options on American, United, Merrill Lynch… stock just before the attack?

Why were the FBI told to not investigate the Bin Laden family links in the US?

If the CIA met with Bin Laden last July, why didn't they try to arrest him?

If the US is serious about ridding the world of terrorism, why do we continue to fund and train terrorists?

Why are we bombing Afghanistan, when none of the alleged bombers actually came from there, could there be another reason for our presence in that region, like oil?

Is the war against Afghanistan illegal?

What are Bush's, Cheney's and Rice's connections to the oil industry?

What are Bush's and Cheney's connections to the drug industry?

Why is the evidence being destroyed when an investigation of the World Trade Center collapse is needed?

Why seal Presidential records?

Why intimidate professors from speaking out against this war?

Why has the U.S. military been establishing working relations with the Uzbek military for several years?

What other military involvement does the U.S. have in the Central Asian Republics?

Why are U.S. military personnel or material assistance going to the Philippines, Indonesia, and Colombia as well?

What relationship did various U.S. agencies and their contractors have with the Taliban, either directly or through Pakistani or Saudi agencies or contractors?

Why does the U.S. overlook Pakistani drug lords who refine and export half to two-thirds of the world’s heroin despite its avowed determination to rid the world of drugs?

Why has the Dept. of Justice stopped its investigation of the Bank of Credit and Commerce International despite its admitted heavy involvement in laundering drug money?


(Links to some of these questions and answers are posted at-http://www.communitycurrency.org/9-11.html)


I believe we all were heartened and inspired by one another. When the meeting was over, we bade our farewells, gave hugs.

Outside with our brave supporters we held hands and looked into one another's eyes. I felt such a great sense of love for all those who had come, and to those who were part of the delegation for their courage, their love of life, and their belief in the quest for truth, and felt a wave of energy from those who couldn't be there physically, but were in spirit.












by critical thinker for truth and justice
Thank you so much for organizing this! It is critically important that this effort continue to build and grow. The media was there and did not air anything???

> What are Bush's, Cheney's and Rice's connections to the oil industry?

Extensive! But need further investigation. Your list did not mention the long-standing motive of oil companies to establish a "stable" government in Afghanistan, which has been the subject of congressional hearings, etc.

> What are Bush's and Cheney's connections to the drug industry?

Do you include illicit drugs (e.g., Afghanistan-produced heroin) in the general scope of "drug industry"? If so it should be more explicitly stated, people generally would assume you mean the "legitimate" drug industry otherwise.

+ + +

Gee, Feinstein BELIEVES IN BUSH and has a "different worldview" than you. He's going from Monarch to Deity as the blind faith continues, I suppose. Did anyone record that statement? Video would be priceless.

Another thread would expose how truly terrifying her actions have been throughout her political career.
Excellent report......I READ all your questions....and I BELIEVE you probably knowmost of the answers...ITS all about OIL of course....then LIES .....Billions.....DECEIT....more Billions..Then...so more lies, few more thousand victims....Propaganda....Hidden Agendas.....more LIES...Arrogance....Self INTERESTS..Psychological Manipulations on a GLOBAL schemes just to make sure that the FEAR ...factor is well in place, so that CIVIL LIBERTIES can be REMOVED ....We are being mislead ...from way back....But now are Freedom is at stake...............and much more...if we refuse to swallow thoses LIES......
That is the shit. A congressional inquiry into the cause of the 9/11 ?

Sounds good to me!

I am so glad to see people getting up and asking
the sort of things that I would be making more of a song and dance about if I could just get off my
arse long enough to actually do it.


The most important questions, as I see it are
(in order..)


- Why were no fighter planes dispatched to intercept the four hijacked planes on September 11h , in violation of standard procedures?

- Why were the FBI told to not investigate the Bin Laden family links in the US?

- Did the CIA have foreknowledge of the attack ? - who tried to profit with put options on American, United, Merrill Lynch. stock just before the attack?

- Why seal Presidential records?


Who knows. Maybe the story is exactly as Bush paints it, and there is no case to answer.

But nevertheless, these 'anomalies' do seem to persist. (The paranoid, anti-semtic comments of people such as ex-ISI head General Gul notwithstanding).

So I'd like to see a few more of these questions, *particularly the first one* being openly asked, and answered by some of our mainstream media if not by our courts...

hmmmm OK.. I'll settle for just the liberal, emocrat media at a pinch ;_)

If this is the best our mainstream media can do (ABC report on the fighter cover) then god help us.
http://playlist.yahoo.com/makestream.dll?ID=1726040

[NB: note comment at end about this report being edited by our security forces.. ]
by frisona
why don't we hear in europe about the protests against this war people do in the US?
reading or listning the news about american peoples meaning it seems all americans are on the same line as mr. bush and company.
thank you
by tyro (nerradyar [at] HOTMAIL.COM)
WHO is: USEC Inc?
If this site isnt a propaganda pit or has any truth, answer this one question and prepare for edu_

Thank you for your time,

Tyro..
by sskinner (tduncan [at] pacifier.com)
Dear Frisona
No one hears this stuff in the US. One has to search the web for it. Lots of people are thinking about the links, but few are talking; many are not interested. alot of Americans support the US' imperial grab. There is great concern about the fate of the world by a few, and I hope we can persuade others to take heed, before it is too late. Keep asking questions!!
by Sam Rafael
that you people are fucking morons.
by Z.L.
Please see http://www.goatse.cx for WEF info.
by rjj
damn, this is getting ridiculous. spammers must have a ton of time on their hands, because the level of bullshit on this site is rising to epidemic proportions.
by jim
I agree with the above statement that you peple are fucking morons!! Why cant you just simply understand that 3000 of our fellow citizens of this great country are dead. You people sit in your little socialist bubble of fantisy land up in the Bay Area and have'nt a clue about the reality of the world. Other people want to kill us for simply being part of the greatest country that ever existed. The freedoms we enjoy in this country would be destroyed forever if we allow whiny liberal eco-terrorist bastards have their way. America has to be involved in the dealings of all world affairs. Its our duty as the singular superpower in the world today. It is a simple fact of the history of the entire human race, those with power i.e. US, England, Rome..., use their power to influence other states with lesser power. We must destroy the terrorists, and their host nations before they even have a chance to inflict harm again on American soil. If we have to bomb every mid-east nation to the ground, killing thousands of them to protect us here so be it. I'm sure your views would be different if the terrorists bombed your local Starbucks or your local socialist bookstore.
by canadian tired of the bs
Before you go off on why nobody should ask questions,
http://www.angelfire.com/retro/malcontentx
http://www.angelfire.com/retro/malcontentx/questions.html#index.html

I'd say more folk than utopian socialists have answers at hand if they risked asking the questions. Keep asking folks....
by mackno
In 'add your comment' I read a very interesting comment from Jim. We live in a free world, he says, but he is not able to tell us who's free, nor why criminals of any sort have a lot of power, bush (father & son) cheney etc.
He is so sure that someone outside usa want to bomb usa, is he able to tell us why? Why anybody want to hurt a innocent country? Does he know that this country is the most terroristic and criminal country of the planet, second is israel. How many million people died at the hand (directly or indirectly) by usa? (some estimates suggests more than 250million). Does he know what freedom is? Are the police, cia, dia, dea, bush and others defending freedom? Freedom of what? to make fat criminals? The simple fact is in this country very few people believe that democracy has anything to so with them, they got misery (it doen't matter which moroons party).
I think that Jim in indoctrinated in such a way that is not able to differentiate facts from fiction. Hollywood may make him believe we live in a free society, sic,but in the realities we are slaves to the corporates and parasites of any kind and the most paramount to all excrements of political lobbies.
by Modes of Historical Discourse
Two fundamental premises underpin the work of our collaborative action research group, as we attempt to bring about change in classroom learning and teaching through a focus on discourse and activity.{1} First, we believe that learning is an integral aspect of any form of activity - a condition of living, not merely a preparation for life in the future. Second, we believe that education at all levels must be conceived in terms of dialogue: an attempt, through the use of various modes of discourse, to develop understanding of, and to act effectively and responsibly in, our shared but diverse social and physical environment. The basis for these assumptions is to be found in our reflections on our own personal and professional experiences, as these have been enriched and given focus through our reading and discussion of the works of writers in a wide variety of intellectual traditions.

Particularly important for our group, in this latter respect, has been the confluence of ideas, stemming from the work of Dewey (1938) in the United States and Vygotsky (1978, 1987) in Russia, that is currently referred to as social constructivism. A central theme in the work of both these scholars is that human beings learn in the course of participating in purposeful joint activity as, with assistance from more expert others, they master the use of the material and intellectual tools and practices that mediate the achievement of the desired outcomes of those activities. This conception challenges the assumptions on which traditional practice is based by rejecting the view of education as the transmission of decontextualized skills anditems of knowledge which, having been acquired, may subsequently be put to use in "real" activities. Instead, learning is seen as "an integral and inseparable aspect of social practice," a concomitant of "engaged, dilemma-driven" activity, in which "agent, activity, and the world mutually constitute each other" (Lave and Wenger, 1991, pp.31, 33). Rather than merely adding to the student's fund of knowledge, learning involves a "process of transformation of participation itself," which occurs as a function of all participants "transforming roles and understanding in the activities in which they (currently) participate" (Rogoff, 1994, p.209).

Such a transformative view of education has far reaching implications for the role of the teacher in the teaching-learning relationship. In particular, it makes clear that, to be effective as teachers, there must be a continuing transformation of our practice that is shaped by and shapes our developing understanding of our students, of the topics that are selected, and of how our joint engagement with these topics is affected by the nature of the activities in which they are embedded. With this transformation of practice as our motive, the major focus of our action research has been on developing modes of classroom activity that provide frequent opportunities for our students, as well as ourselves, to be transformative learners through collaborative participation in productive activities that, individually and collectively, we find interesting and relevant.

However, to base the curriculum on the criteria of interest and relevance alone would be both limited and limiting. A teacher's curricular decisions must also be informed by a critical analysis of the historical, cultural and political context in which they are taken. Adopting this larger perspective, it seems clear to us that there are many important domains of human experience and understanding that the students in our schools would be unlikely to engage with unless teachers deliberately attempt to kindle interest in them and provide guidance and assistance as students begin to participate in the relevant practices. This is particularly the case with the academic disciplines that underpin the subjects of the school curriculum. In this context, we are also conscious of our responsibility to meet the expectations of society, as these are set out in the sequence of topics for study in the "Common Curriculum" (OMET, 1993) and in the accompanying specification of "learning outcomes".

However, while agreeing that it is important that students should master the "generic knowledge and skills" that form the core of the curriculum, we are convinced that, whenever possible, these should be treated, not as ends in themselves, but as means to be used in solving problems of practical and social significance. At the same time, as well as the procedural knowledge that is constructed through participation in productive "hands-on" activity, we believe that students should also develop the understanding that is the outcome of the "minds-on" activity in which personal experience is extended and enriched through being juxtaposed and integrated with culturally-developed information and modes of interpretation and representation (Cobb, 1994; Kalantzis & Cope, 1993). In this latter respect, an important part of the teacher's responsibility is to introduce the various forms of metalanguage that enable knowledge itself to be reflected upon, and to encourage students to adopt a critical and reflective stance to both the ideas they encounter and the actions they perform. For it is in this way that they are best enabled to participate in classroom activities as autonomous, intentional and transformational learners, who are not restricted to the ways of acting and thinking of their immediate communities but able to extend and change them through their own critical and creative participation (Engestrom, 1991; Scardamalia and Bereiter, 1994).

Finally, we are convinced that, whatever activities are selected in the light of the above criteria, it is essential that, as a central feature of the process, students are encouraged to collaborate in "negotiating and renegotiating meaning" (Bruner, 1990, p.123) in a continuing attempt to construct an understandingof the material and social world that will enhance their further participation in joint activity. This brings us to our secondemphasis - the transformations that are mediated through dialogue.

The Dialogic Nature of Discourse

In the historical development of human societies, as well as in the development of their individual members, the propensity for collaborative meaning-making plays a critical role. As the mediator of joint activity, language enables participants to coordinate their actions - to negotiate goals and evaluate outcomes. This is its interpersonal function. At the same time, in its ideational function, it provides a means of representing objects and events and the relationships between them; it thus constitutes a powerful tool for collaborative remembering, thinking and problem solving. In this role, as Halliday puts it, language functions as "a theory of human experience" (1993, p.97).

Developmentally, language appears first in the oral mode and, for most forms of activity, it is oral discourse that remains theprimary mode of interpersonal interaction. However, where the activity requires the accumulation and communication of accurate information as the basis for systematic knowledge construction, the transient nature of oral discourse makes it an inadequate tool. It was primarily to serve these latter ideational functions that, historically, the written mode of language was developed (Halliday, 1985).

As a means for mediating intellectual activity, the crucial characteristic of writing is that it gives a permanent representation to meaning. Written texts can be read and re-read, silently or aloud, and - either by the writer or by subsequent readers - they can be critically interrogated and revised, with each successive version of the text providing the basis for further reflection and reformulation. Thus, as Olson puts it: "What literacy contributes to thought is that it turns the thoughts themselves into worthy objects of contemplation" (1994, p.277). By the same token, becoming literate can be thought of, at least in part, as appropriating this powerful tool for thinking with (Lotman, 1988), and of bringing under conscious and deliberate control meaning-making capacities that, previously, were only deployed spontaneously in oral discourse (Vygotsky, 1987). However, once literate modes of discourse have been mastered, the practices that they enable can, to a considerable degree, be carried out also in speech.

Whether in the oral or the written mode, however, discourse is essentially social in nature. Furthermore, because it is constituted of a series of contributions that are sequentially inserted into the ongoing flow of activity, it is also inherently dialogic. Intended to play a part in advancing the activity towards the goal to which participants are orienting, each contribution is a strategic act that is both responsive to thespeaker/writer's interpretation of the current state of affairs and assumes, in turn, a further responsive act (Bakhtin, 1986). However, in claiming that discourse is necessarily social and dialogic, it is not being suggested that there is no place for disagreement. On the contrary, since any community includes diverse voices and points of view, argument and debate should be both expected and encouraged. Indeed, as a variety of studies have shown, advances in action and understanding are often best achieved through attempts to resolve disagreement.

Discourse is undoubtedly the most salient aspect of educational activity. In classrooms of all kinds, some form of discourse, either spoken or written, is going on for most of the time. However, focusing on its tool-like function leads to the important recognition that this discourse is not an end in itself, but a means of achieving the goals of the larger activities that constitute the object of education. Furthermore, it is not the only means. Non-verbal actions of various kinds, such as observing, experimenting, drawing, model-making and so on, are also important ways of making meaning. Together with talking, writing and reading, they make up the semiotic tool-kit that participants master through using the different tools in complementary and mutually reinforcing ways to achieve (and at the same time to develop) the goals of the activity in which they are engaged (Wells, 1994). In an important sense, therefore, allthese mediational means are dialogic.

Unfortunately, however, the potential for collaborative knowledge building that is inherent in a dialogic conception of educational activity has remained largely untapped in most educational institutions. Both the transmissionary mode of curriculum delivery and the narrowly individualistic and competitive ethos that pervades most classrooms has militated against its realization. Nor, in most cases, has the current enthusiasm for "cooperative learning" brought about a significant change. For simply having students carry out some tasks in groups does little to alter the traditional orientation, unless the nature of the overall activity is itself radically changed and the roles of the participants renegotiated. It was thus to bring about such a transformation of classroom activities and of the discourses that mediate them that our group of classroom and university educators came together to form an action research community. However, as our growing understanding has been shaped by the experience of working together, we have come to realise that, if we want to bring about the sort of changes implied by a transformational dialogic conception of education, we also have to focus on our own modes of discourse, both as practices and as objects of investigation.


Overlapping Communities: Our Classrooms, Our Schools and Our Research Project

In the first phase of our research (1991-94), we began with a focus on oral discourse in the learning and teaching of science (Wells, 1995; Allen et al., in preparation). However, as the research proceeded, it became clear that, in order to understand as well as to intentionally provide for the sort of practices and conditions of learning implied by the conception of education outlined above, we needed to broaden our focus.

First, we needed to extend the scope of our project to include all areas of the school curriculum. Whilst the demands of timetabling may require the sharp differentiation of "subjects", the developmental needs of the student as a whole person do not, as is emphasized in our provincial curriculum policy (OMET, 1993). Furthermore, particularly for the elementary and intermediate school teachers in our project, it was natural to wish to extend to other areas the understandings gained in relation to science. Yet science proved to have been a well-chosen starting point, for it had led us to see the essentially collaborative nature of knowledge building, the importance of "progressive discourse" in this process (Bereiter, 1994) and, in particular, the value of an "inquiry" orientation in creating the sort of community in which transformational, dialogic learning and teaching can be enacted. In our current work, therefore, as we investigate the interplay between action and the different modes of discourse in classroom activity, we are exploring what these key concepts might mean when they are brought to bear on other areas of the school curriculum.

Second, with our growing understanding of the relationship between learning and participation in a community of inquiry, we have come to recognize that the changes we are attempting to bring about in classrooms are, to a considerable extent, dependent on making changes at other levels in the institution of education as a whole, most notably in the ways in which policy is developed and enacted in schools and school boards, and in the preparation andprofessional development of teachers, administrators and teacher educators. In our different places of work, therefore, each of us is attempting to develop a community of inquiry among the colleagues in our immediate environment, where one focus of our inquiry is to explore the nature of the practices of the school community and their relationship with those of the classroom communities formed by individual teachers with their students.

The recognition of these as two overlapping communities, whose practices have consequences for each other, makes it equally important for us to ask how transformational and dialogic is the culture of the school community wherein teachers learn as they teach. However, the search for answers to this question is beyond the scope of this chapter, as is exploration of the nature of the relationship between school and classroom communities. Rather, this chapter focuses on the third overlapping community - that of our own research team. But as we look more closely at our own practices, we undoubtedly need to consider how they relate to those of the other two.

Modes of Discourse Within Our Communities of Inquiry

Like any community, our research team uses both oral and written modes of discourse as tools for a variety of practices. Practices which use the oral mode of discourse include our regular meetings, our social gatherings, interviews conducted with students and members of the research team, classroom talk, and our conference presentations. Practices which rely on the written mode of discourse include our e-mail, our ethnographic notes of classroom activities, our research reports, and our published or in-progress writings. In addition, for purposes of research, many of our oral practices are recorded either in audio or video form and extracts transcribed and entered into a computer-supported database. For example significant parts of our classroom discourse and our monthly meetings are in the form of transcripts, making them more accessible for analysis.

Considered from the point of view of the different media involved,oral and written discourse may, on first examination, appear to be very different. Closer analysis of our practices, however, suggests that the medium may be less important than the practices that the discourse serves. It is this observation that the next section of our chapter will address.

A Comparison of the Practices Served by Meetings and E-mail Communication

Probably for all members of our research community, the preferred mode of discourse is some kind of face-to-face interaction. But, because we work in widely separated locations, the opportunities to meet and talk are relatively infrequent. To supplement our monthly meetings, therefore, we have had to explore the potential of other modes of discourse to pursue our collaboration in inquiry. Of particular importance, in this respect, is our use of e-mail to establish connectivity among ourselves in a way that transcends the constraints of time and space. Taken together, meetings and e-mail communication form one component of our oral and written discourse data, which have common as well as unique features.

What are these features and how do they shape our practices and learning, individually and as a community? A recurring feature is that both our e-mail communication and our face-to-face interactions are used as a means for celebrating and maintaining friendships and for providing support. They are also used to define and establish membership, since, over the course of the year, we have had several discussions as to who may or may not participate in our meetings and our e-mail network. Viewed in this manner, the line between the purposes served by our oral and written discourses, in the form of meetings, social gatherings and e-mail communication, is blurred. In our use of the two modes for such practices, we currently think that they do not differ significantly.

However, unlike our regular meetings, during which the conversations are public, e-mail accords individual members the potential to engage in private conversations. Depending on the nature of these conversations, e-mail has the potential, but not necessary, consequence of establishing exclusion and inclusion of various members, thereby affecting the culture of a particular community. These features and their consequences are not unlike the manner in which students in classrooms exploit written discourse, be it to counteract the public nature of classrooms or to establish a culture of inner and outer circles or of hierarchy amongst various groups. When the written mode is used for such practices, we would argue that writing serves as a more powerful tool than oral discourse in the maintenance of social networks and structures. It is the recognition of the existence of such distinctions between the two modes of discourse in adult practices that will enable us to discern them amongst our students in schools and their consequences for students' behaviour and learning.

Nevertheless, the establishment and maintenance of social relationships is by no means the most significant of our e-mail practices. E-mail also serves as a tool for the ethnographic documentation of events, or issues of policy, as they occur in our classroom or school communities. For example, an extended discussion developed recently around the range of practices among our schools and school boards with respect to assessment, evaluation and communicating with parents about students' progress. When used to serve such a purpose, e-mail as written discourse is far more significant than the oral discourse of our meetings. This is because the act of composing brings the writer to re-visit the event or issue in a more deliberate and thoughtful manner.

This use of e-mail to document our practices in the other two communities also has the effect of changing the research practice of ethnographic note-taking, which is by and large private. E-mail, being public, changes the act of documentation; instead of writing for self as reader, one writes for the community of co-researchers as well. Added to this, the ethnography as written is often not a static or one-shot account. Rather, it has the potential of transforming from a product to an interactive and dynamic process. This happens when co-researchers respond with analogous or different accounts, resulting in a richer and more complex portrait of school practices in the wider community in which we work. This particular use of e-mail, we conjecture, changes teacher-researchers' understandings and, over time, their actions as well. Certainly, one consequential outcome for us is that, through e-mail, we have the opportunity to locate and view our own practices within larger and overlapping communities, thereby developing greater sociocultural understanding of the world of schools and classrooms, and of their ramifications.

Equally important is that, in employing e-mail in this manner, we are experimenting with its use as a joint research methodology that is of value to teacher-researchers. Any classroom ethnographer will attest that their observational notes are often successful in detailing the observable behaviour of participants. But it is a much more challenging task to ascertain and describe their thought processes, and the intentions and motivations that underpin their behaviour. However, as we examine the ethnographic accounts in our e-mail communications, we realise that they provide rich vignettes of teachers' thought processes in their planning or responding to their enacted curriculum, of their visions and expectations for their students, of their beliefs and values, and of the factors that shape their current actions. When, as a group, we perceive our e-mail writings as ethnographies of teachers' thinking and analyse them for patterns, uncertainties and surprises, our efforts have transformational value both for ourselves and for the larger community of teacher-researchers.

It is this aspect of our e-mail practice to which our regular meetings are in some ways similar. We have, over the course of our first year as a research community, taken a metacognitive stance to our meetings when, at intervals, we have reflected upon how we have conducted past meetings and what purposes they have served. These reflections have gradually led us to identify various features, of which one that we particularly value is the practice of using our meetings for the development of a dialectical understanding of practice and theory. It is to such an end that we had a series of meetings during which individual members of the community both provided a qualitative account of one aspect of their practice in the other two communities and looked at it from a theoretical and interpretive perspective. Indeed, it is precisely on such occasions, we believe, that we are most fully engaged in transformational dialogic learning.

Linking The Practices of Overlapping Communities Through Oral and Written Research Activities

The objectives of our individual and collective research agendas also entail interviews with the students of the teacher members o our research team, video or audio recordings of units of study in classroom communities, and teachers working together as school communities. These not only provide us with data for our research agendas, but they also capture the modes of discourse in the overlapping communities of classrooms and schools.

The data we have of our modes of discourse in the two aforementioned communities are further enriched by our efforts to make permanent records of some of those research activities that are conducted orally. One example is transcripts of our interviews; another is the oral and written discourse of our joint engagement in preparing for conference presentations, or our collaborative writing of research reports as well as papers for publication. When these research activities are audio or video taped and when drafts of our writing are kept, together they provide us with added discourse data that demonstrate the complementary role of oral and written discourse in joint activity.

From our current work, we observe that when transcripts (that employ the written mode to create a paper trace of oral discourse) are examined intentionally and critically, they provide occasions for us, individually or collectively, to work within our "zones of proximal development" (Vygotsky, 1978). This is only possible, however, if each of us exploits the dialectical juxtaposition of our actions, intentions, and intertextual knowledge-base. In other words, analysis of any artificat, action or discourse is, by itself, an insufficient condition for tranformational learning to occur. What is also required is the exploitation of one's theories of knowledge and expertise as lenses for meaning-making. Unless we look at our practices through the lens of a theoretical framework,and unless connections are made between our practices and other educational practices, some of which are similar and some different, our research activities will not have transformational consequences.

Working together as a community to provide a dialogic counterpart to an individual member's practice and thinking, as we explore practices captured on video or in transcripts, has also enabled us to make parallels between the learning we are experiencing as a research community and that of our students and ourselves in our classroom communities. And, in both cases, we realize, it is not so much which mode of discourse is used that is significant; rather, it is whether, in whatever mode, the discourse is progressive. Subjecting our research activities to this question is, in fact, the first step in changing our participation and practices into those that our conception of education proposes. If we are successful in this, we shall engage in learning which is transformational for us, and simultaneously we shall have profound effects on the learning that goes on in the classroom and school communities of which each of us are also participant members.


Conclusion

In all three communities - classroom, school and research team - discourse is an essential tool for collaborative activity. But, because it is taken for granted, it is rarely examined critically. In this investigation of our own modes of discourse - as practice, as research activity, and as research data - we have highlighted a possible methodology for researching into the complex links among the three communities and the consequences each has for the others. We have also sketched the potential of such an undertaking as an intentional and ongoing form of teachers' professional development. What is most significant for us about our analysis, however, is that it has led us to see that it is the dialogue about our new understandings and their implications for practice that changes the nature of our research, from research that is being done as an end in itself to research that transforms our living, learning and teaching.



References

Bakhtin, M.M. (1986) Speech genres and other late essays. Austin: University of Texas Press.

Bereiter, C. (1994) Implications of postmodernism for science, or, science as progressive discourse. Educational Psychologist, 29 (1): 3-12.

Bruner, J.S. (1990) Acts of meaning. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Cobb, P. (Ed.) (1994) Constructivism in mathematics and science education: An exchange. Educational Researcher, 23 (7): 4-23.

Dewey, J. (1938) Education and experience. New York: Collier Books.

Engestrom, Y. (1991) 'Non scolae sed vitae discimus': Toward overcoming the encapsulation of school learning. Learning and Instruction, 1: 243-259.

Halliday, M.A.K. (1985) Spoken and written language. Geelong, Vic.: Deakin University Press. (Republished by Oxford University Press, 1989.)

Halliday, M.A.K. (1993) Towards a language-based theory of learning. Linguistics and Education, 5 (2): 93-116.

Kalantzis, M. And Cope, B. (1993) Histories of pedagogy, cultures of schooling. In B. Cope and M. Kalantzis (Eds.) The powers of literacy: A genre approach to teaching writing. Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press.

Lave, J. and Wenger, E. (1991) Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Lotman, Y.M. (1988) Text within a text. Soviet Psychology, 26 (3): 32-51.

Olson, D.R. (1994) The world on paper. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ontario Ministry of Education and Training, (1993) The common curriculum: grades 1-9. Toronto: The Queen’s Printer for Ontario.

Rogoff, B. (1994) Developing understanding of the idea of Communities of Learners. Mind, Culture, and Activity, 1 (4): 209- 229.

Scardamalia, M. and Bereiter, C. (1994) Computer support for knowledge-building communities. The Journal of the Learning Sciences, 3 (3): 265-283.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1978) Mind in society. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

Vygotsky, L.S. (1987) Thinking and speech. In R.W. Rieber and A.S. Carton (Eds.), The collected works of L.S. Vygotsky, Volume 1: Problems of general psychology, (Trans. N. Minick). New York: Plenum.

Wells, G. (1994) Text, talk and inquiry: Schooling as semiotic apprenticeship. In N. Bird et al. (Eds.) Language and learning. Hong Kong: Institute of Language in Education and University of Hong Kong Department of Curriculum Studies.

Wells, G. (1995) Language and the inquiry-oriented curriculum. Curriculum Inquiry, 25 (3): 233-269.


Note

The writing of this chapter was supported by a grant from the Spencer Foundation to the Ontario Institute for Studies in Education. It is based on a presentation made at the International Conference on Action Research, University of California, Davis, in April 1995, in the preparation of which all members of the "Developing Inquiring Communities in Education Project" participated: Patrick Allen, Zoe Donoahue, Karen Hume, Monica McGlynn-Stewart, Myriam Shechter, Barbara Smith and Mary Ann Van Tassell, as well as the authors. We should like to express our gratitude to the Spencer Foundation and to the other members of the DICEP team for their contributions.
by JC (meanspiritedJC [at] hotmail.com)
Yes, America is the terrorist nation. We're the nation torturing, maiming, raping and killing dissidents -not the filthy fundamentalist ragheads of the middle east. And we're doing it all for oil! And Israel is our partner in crime!! <p>I'll never understand the mentality of the pseudo-intellectual crowd that forces youall to identify with the so-called "underdog" despite common sense. Sigh. Good thing most of you are safely quarantined in academia where your harm is limited to influencing gullible undergrads.
by MexicAnarchist
Have you been so brainwashed by all this pseudo-patriotic hysteria that you can not even think for yourself? Or were you just born as a racist, gullible, bag of crap? For every three americans killed in the WTC, a hundred people have been murdered by the U.S. government. If you got off your lazy, naive ass and did your own homework you would see the truth. Intellectuals THINK, whereas you, dear bag of crap, do not. If you don't like the threat of being blown up (which is so over-hyped right now) maybe you should ask our government to quit blowing up countries.
You want to see those "ragheads"? Go to RAWA.org and see all the innocent lives being taken in the name of our corrupt fascist government. Or would you rather keep on living in your little bubble of ignorance and stupidity?
by shu shine
Are you aware that you provide links on your website to revisionist antisemit people which negate the holocaust?
if you follow carol valentines public action you end up in this field of neo-nazism like i would call it.
her investigation on the 9-11 attacks are interessting, but if you go further you find terrible antisemit websites with hitler citations.
by virtual geographer
you can get to anti-Semitic websites from ANYWHERE on the web.

So what?
by AR
there is no evidence against the Mossad. all accusations are coming from anti-semites . for the record i'm not jewish
by AR
anyone who makes comments like this mackno character should be required to visit ground zero- them maybe you would get your head out of your ass.
by lesfrerespetards (lesfrerespetards [at] yahoo.fr)
ballandchainmedia.jpg
Richard Mueller, FBI
======================================================
Why did the FBI close their files in Mid 1996 (marked Secret and coded 199) to investigate two of Osama bin Laden's relatives in Washington and a Muslim organisation, the World Assembly of Muslim Youth?
When did you stop monitoring Khalid Al-Midhar and Nawaq Alhazm?
Why did you stop monitoring Khalid Al-Midhar and Nawaq Alhazm in August 2000?
What did you decide after the French Secret Service told you in August 2001, that Zacarias Massoui might be involved in a hijack of a commercial passenger jet?
Why did George W.Bush stop inquiries into the terrorist connections of the Bin Laden family in early 2001?
Did you get any information of the Florida police or any other police officers that Mohammad Atta was searched because of an expired Visa?
If so, at which time?
Did you get any information of the Florida police or any other police officers that Mohammad Atta was searched because of driving a car without a license?
Did you get any information of the Broward County police, Florida that Mohammad Atta was searched because of driving a car without a license?
Did you get any information of the Florida police or any other police officers that Mohammad Atta was searched because of an incident at Miami Airport?
Who gave the decision of John O'Neills resignement to stop investigating Al-Aqueada accounts?
Who gave the decision to give him a security job at the World Trade Center?
Did John O'Neill meet anyone of the FEMA in the night of September 1oth?
Why did you stop inform the public about the anthrax investigations in November 2001?
Did you ever investigate at any of these institutes:
USArmy Medical Research Institute for Infectious Diseases (Ft. Detrick, MD)#*
Dugway Proving Ground (Utah)#*
Naval Research Medical Center and associated military labs (MD)#
Battelle Memorial Institute (Ohio; plus laboratories in many other locations)#*
Duke University Medical School, Clinical Microbiology Lab. (NC)
VA Medical Center, Durham (NC)
USDA laboratory and Iowa State College of Veterinary Medicine, Ames (Iowa)
LSU College of Veterinary Medicine*
Northern Arizona State University (Arizona)*
Illinois Institute of Technology Research Institute (IL)
University of New Mexico Health Sciences Center, Albuquerque (NM)*
Institute for Genomic Research (MD)
Chemical and Biological Defense Establishment, Porton Down (UK)*
Center for Applied Microbiology and Research, Porton (UK)*
Defense Research Establishment, Suffield (CA)*
In addition, CDC, NIH, and Los Alamos?
What about New Jersey Institute of Wildlife Fund in Trenton New Jersey, who examined animal anthrax in 2000?
Can you explain, why some media reports said, that two of the hijackers had bought tickets for flights scheduled after the Sept. 11 attacks?
Can you explain, why Ahmed Alghamdi, who was on the United Airlines plane that hit the World Trade Center, had also purchased tickets for a flight the next day from Dulles Airport in Washington D.C. to Saudi Arabia?
Can you explain, why Mohammad Atta also appears to have been booked on a Delta flight from Baltimore to San Francisco; the date of that flight however is unclear?
Which two men did Mohammad Atta and Marwan Al-Shehh met in Harry's Bar
at the Helmsley Hotel in Manhattan (East 42nd Street) on September 8th 2001?
Who called the Westmoreland County 911 and claimed that he is sitting in a plane which had been hijacked?
Why none of the 19 hijackers appeared on the passenger lists?
Can you explain, why Muslims frequent bars and drink alchoholic beverages or leave their Qurans there?
Can you explain, why the so called professional hijackers used credit cards with their correct names, and allowed drivers licenses with photos to be Xeroxed?
Can you explain, why the hi-jackers did force passengers to call relatives?
Can you explain, why the hijackers were able to deviate from the flight plan and crash into their targets without any effort from law enforcement or the military to stop them?
Which passport of the hijackers did you find in the rubble of the WTC and who found it at what time?
How could the FBI distinguish between "regular" Muslims and hijacker Muslims on those flights?
Can you explain the coincidence why no other "innocent" muslim was on board of any of these flights?
Did you just go through the passenger lists culling out the Muslim-sounding names and labeling the people bearing those names as hijackers?
Can you explain, why Mohammad Atta left his bag at the airport or the employees
didn't put it on board?
Who found his bag?
How you was sure, it was his bag?

Richard Mueller, FBI (Pt.2)

Can you explain, why Mohammad Atta did put a video "how to fly planes",
an uniform and his last will into his bag, knowing that he will commit suicide anyway?
Can you explain, why Mohammad Atta did leave his drivers license in a rental car?
Can you explain, why none of the 8 indestructible Black Boxes had been found at all 3 crash centers?
Why didn't the FBI release the air traffic controllers protocols?
Why did the FBI not release the Flight Data Recorder info, absolutely harmless?
Who was that gentleman on the street on Septemner 11th at about 8:48 a.m. with a cam-corder in
his hands making the video, which captured and recorded the incident of the
first plane hitting the tower?
Why he never appeared in the media again?
How did the FBI receive a tip from a passenger who boarded a different plane and
reached his destination safely that he had a confrontation with two Middle
Eastern gentlemen at the Logan airport in Boston, MA?
Who gave the FBI the tip to storm the Westin Hotel in Boston on September 12th?
Can you explain, why helping hands of the hijackers were still waiting in that Hotel and ordered "a pizza with black olives and took short naps before?" 29 hours after the initial attack?
Why did the FBI ignore other ties of Bin Ladens family, who later had been able to leave the United States without further investigations?
(including Sheik Bakr Mohammed bin Laden, Mohammed M. bin Laden)
What do you know about these 6 hijackers identities who are still alive?
Can you explain the odd coincidence why almost everyone of them are pilots?
Was there never a reason to change the list with the 19 hijackers?
What happened with Ayub Ali Khan and Mohammed Jaweed Azmath who have been in jail since September 2001, because of a possession of box cutters on a train?
Who gave the tip to arrest them?
How many other arabs have been arrested since September 11th?
What do you know about the current whereabouts of Said Bahaji, who was claimed to buy the tickets for some of the hijackers?
What exactly did you do on September 18th, when an employee of Batelle Memorial Institute was involved in a so called anthrax hoax on that day?
Did you ever arrest him?
Why did you start to investigate on that case again in December 2001?
Can you explain why eye-witness Madeline Amy Sweeney described how hijackers stabbed passengers and then diverted the plane and why The FBI has named five hijackers on board Flight 11, whereas Ms Sweeney spotted only four.
Also, the seat numbers she gave were different from those registered in the hijackers' names?
Why did it take 4 months before you promoted Ramsi Binalschibhs name again,
who was a good friend of Mohammad Atta and lived in his same apartment in Hamburg?
Why did it take 4 months until December 11th, when Zacarias Moussaoui is charged over September 11 attacks when his case was known worldwide for months, but not promoted in the American media?
Whatever happened with Lotfi Raissi who was arrested in UK for teaching the terrorist pilots?
What is the current status of the investigation of Mamoun Darkazanli Import-Export-Company in Hamburg and Al Taqwa Management Organisation in Lugano?
What was in the memo of Dr. Leonard Horowitz, a Public health consumer advocate and author of "Death in the Air" on October 1, 2001, almost two weeks before the first anthrax letter was sent from Trenton, New Jersey to the American media building in Boca Raton, Florida?
What do you think about his other letter from November 13th, in which he claimed, that BAYER is behind the anthrax infections?
What do you think about the possibility that US BioDefense laboratories sent
the anthrax-laced letters to get a new budget for their research?
Did you ever recognize the statement of former UN-weapons inspecteur of Iraq, Richard Spertzel, who told ABC, "...he knows only five scientists in the USA who would be in the situation to produce such a fine, highly developed spore material.."?
Why did it take 48 hours to inform Bob Stevens, that he has anthrax?
Can you still not explain, why you never found envelopes at Bob Stevens,
Amelie Lundgren and Mia Nguyen?
Can you explain the odd coincidence that Microsoft got a hoax anthrax letter
from Malaysia on the same day when President Bush said, that Malaysia might be one of the next targets of the United States?

Richard Mueller, FBI (Pt.3)
=============================================
Is it correct, as FOX reported, that FBI agent Robert Hanssen sold high-tech PROMIS software to Russia, and that Osama bin Laden allegedly purchased it from Russian organized crime sources?
Why did the FBI never investigate in the case Don C Wiley, a BioScientist who
disappeared on November 13th, 2001?
Why did the FBI then start to investigate after his dead body was found on December 22nd 2001, 300 miles away?
Did you ever investigate at the military hydro plant next to his body, when
Workers of that plant found him?
Can you explain, why the media wrote different versions about how, when and where he was found?
Why did the police report then changed after 2 months from suicide to an accident?
What was the result of your investigation in India at a Chinese software company, Huawei Technologies, which has been later cleared of any links to the Taleban in Afghanistan?
Why was Richard Reid able to enter the paris airport twice and who paid for his hotel?
Why did you think that Abdallah Higazy had something to do with the attack on the Twin Towers and why did you report about his pilot radio only almost 4 months later?
Who was the real owner of that radio?
Zacarias Massoui
=====================================================================
Who exactly hired you to learn how to fly passenger jets in the United States?
Who hired your lawyer?
Can you explain, why the FBI or CIA didn't interrogate you between August 2001 and December 2001?
What can you tell us about Ramzi Omar (alias Binalshibh) ?
Admiral William Crowe (former Chairman of two Accountability Review Boards)
+ Al-Hibri (Ex-Porton International UK), Bioport:
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of BioPort in 1997?
Is it correct that the schedule for developing anti-anthrax vaccines was exactly 3 years, starting in 1998?
Mr. Crowe, when did you think about producing anthrax vaccines, before or after the time when you was charged in September 1998 with investigations of the August 7, 1998 bombings of Embassy Nairobi and Embassy Dar Es Salaam?
Dr. John Brown, Finance Director Acambis Inc, Chief Executive in 1997, former Oravax:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that the schedule for developing anti-anthrax vaccines was exactly 3 years, starting in 1998?
Dr. Manfred Schneider , BAYER:
=====================================================================
When exactly did the US Government ask you for help and sending anti-anthrax vaccines to the United States?
When did you start sending the vaccines?
When did you double your production of vaccines?
King Fahd, Saudi Arabia:
=====================================================================
When was the last time George H.W. Bush travelled to South Arabia on behalf of the privately owned Carlyle Group, the 11th largest defense contractor in the U.S. and what was the purpose of that meeting?





George Tenet, CIA:
========================================================
Can you confirm as dailynews yahoo reported, that you already started to monitor Usama Bin Laden in 1998 with the help of 15 afghan agents, who got paid $1,000 a month?
Can you tell us something about the whereabouts of this agents?
Are they still the same agents?
Was Johnny "Mike" Spann one of them?
Was John Walker Lindh one of them?
Is any afghan agent also member of the ISI?
Is any afghan agent also working for Bin Laden?
Is any afghan agent also working at any of the following companies:
UNOCAL, Halliburton, BinLadin Group Inc, Afghan Development Company, Telephone Systems International (TSI) , Consolidated Contractors International,
SG Asia Project Finance, Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC)
Why did you stop to monitor Chalid al-Midhar in 2000 in Malaysia?
When was the first time you mentioned an Al-Quaeda group to any member of the Senate?
At which time did you find the Bin Laden Home Video?
Who found the video?
Why was it possible to find that video at a time when none of the Northern Alliance or US -Troops have yet
arrived in Kandahar or Jahlalabad?
Is it correct that from the timestamp on the Home Video of Bin Laden you found the HomeVideo of Bin Laden already two weeks after it was produced?
Why didn't you tell the public when and who found the Home Video of Bin Laden?
What can you say about the translation of MONITOR magazine, germany, who proved that the most controversial statements have been translated wrong?
Why did you release that Home Video?
Who gave the final decision to release that HomeVideo?
Do you know the home video of Bin laden of June 2001 in which he praised an attack and can be ordered over the Internet?
What do you think about Bin Ladens statements on Al-Jazeera in June 2001 about the bombing on USS Cole, which has a similar conversation like the one from November 2001s homevideo?
Why do you think Bin Laden stated in Umman Magazine in September 2001 that he wasn't involve in the attack on America on September 1th?
Is Bin Laden still on the payroll of the CIA or ISI?
Is it not correct that Bin Ladin Group Inc. helped to build ToraBora together with the CIA?
Is it correct that you relocated Chalid Al-Midhar and Nawaq Alhamzi in October 2000 again?
Why did you stop monitoring them again a second time?
Did you ever read the trial transcripts of the bombing on the embassies of Kenia and Tansania?
Do you know that some of the Al-Quaeda accounts have been mentioned in that Trial already in February 2001?
Do you know that Al-Zawahiri was mentioned as Bin ladens account manager in the trial transcripts in February 2001?
What was the purpose of the meeting with General Pervez Musharraf in May 2001?
What exactly did the CIA do on September 11th?
Is it correct that some US Airbases have been on high alert on September 1oth and for which purpose?
Did you speak with Richard Cheney on September 11th?
Can you explain, why you released a press statement that Al-Khalifa bin Laden did a telephone call with Bin Laden on September 9th, who is not the real mother of Bin Laden, but Alia Ghanem, who is?
Can you explain, why Bin Ladens real mother Alia Ghanem thinks that Bin Laden didn't plan the attack on America?
Where did you get the photos of all 19 hijackers?
How did you get all 19 names so fast 2 days after the attack?
Why all 19 names still didn't appear on the passenger list 2 days after the hijacker list was released?
How did you get the first five names of the hijackers on the same day of September 11th?
Can you explain, why none of the names appeared on any passenger list, UA and AA gave out to CNN?
How could the hijackers disable the defense systems?
What happened with the updates about the whereabouts of Al-Zawahiri since October 2001?

George Tenet, CIA (Pt.2)
=================================================
What can you tell us about your meetings with the Government of India, Maj.Gen. (retd) Mahmud Ali Durrani, who like Gen.Musharraf, was a blue-eyed boy of the late Gen.Zia-ul-Haq and who is now a close confidante of the self-styled Chief Executive?
Maj.Gen.Durrani had in the past served as the ISI station chief in
Washington and was responsible for the ISI's liaison with the CIA and the FBI. Last year, Jamaat-e-Islami circles in Pakistan had alleged that he had, at the
instance of the CIA, played a role, in consultation with Gen.Musharraf, in
persuading the Hizbul Mujahideen to agree to a cease-fire."
Why did the NSA have been destroying data collected on Americans or US companies since the Sept. 11 attacks?
Why did the CIA or Pentagon trust a document about nuclear bombs in a house in Kandahar, which has been proved as a parody from 1979, which also the NY Times reported?
Who do you think put that fake document into the house or do you think,
That even Al-Aqueade didn't realize that the documents have been useless?
Did you ever investigate in the death of Vladimir Pasechnik,
former director of the Institute of Ultra Pure Biochemical Preparations,
a component of the Soviet biowarfare establishment, Biopreparat in November 2001?
What about the other deaths of Scientists Robert M. Schwartz, Dr. Benito Que and Set Van Nguyen in the same month?
Is Set van Nguyen in any way related to one anthrax victim Mia Nguyen?
What about the death of Nancy Sonnenfeld (FEMA-Wife)?
Why officials lost interest about Sudanese Files on Bin Laden in 1997?
The U.S. AMBASSADOR to Sudan, whose posting ended in 1997 : "The fact is, they were opening the doors, and we weren't taking them up on it. The U.S. failed to reciprocate Sudan's willingness to engage us on some serious questions of terrorism"
General Richard B. Myers, Pentagon
=====================================================================
Why did the Pentagon release a new video version or translation of the Bin Laden Homevideo and can you explain the odd coincidence why that happened only 8 hours after a new translation by german magazine MONITOR on December 2oth?
Can you explain, why all 4 translators have been working for the US-Government before?
What exactly happened on September 11th, 2001 and at which time did you inform President Bush?
Why was President Bush scheduled for a lecture at a school and who decided that at which time?
Richard Armitage, Deputy Secretary of State
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of the meeting in India in May 2001?
Who did you meet at that time?
General Mahmud Ahmad, former head of the ISI
======================================================
What was the decision to step back from your position from the ISI?
Can you explain the decision why the retaliation against the Taliban started on the same day when you stepped down?
Can you tell us, who of the ISI paid $100.000 to Mohammad Atta?
Why do you think, that another secret service has been involved in the attack on America?
Which Secret Service did you talk about?
Can you imagine, that some officials of the ISI also helped to reach that purpose?
Can you imagine, that some officials of the CIA also helped to reach that purpose?
Can you imagine, that some officials of the Mossad paid or helped to reach that purpose?
What was the purpose of your visit in Washington on September 11th, 2001? A.B. "Buzzy" Krongard, CIA:
=====================================================================
Is it true, that the CIA is in possession of a software called PROMIS?
What is the purpose of PROMIS?
Do you or did you own any stocks of United Airlines, American Airlines, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, AXA Re (insurance) which owns 25% of American Airlines, and Munich Re.?
What is your connection to Alex Brown, Deutsche Bank?
Did you give any insider information about Stocks to George Tenet, CIA?
Represantatives of the Consortium Afghan Development Company, e.g. Ghulam Jeloni Popal:
=====================================================
When was the last time you have been in touch with any member of the US-Government?
Who did you meet?
What do you know about Telephone Systems International (TSI) who announced in January 1999 a $240 million contract with the Taliban to establish a network of satellite-call centers in Afghanistan's major cities and a 30,000-line wireless phone system in Kabul?
<http://www.trilliuminvest.com/pages/news/news_detail.asp?ArticleID=103&Status=Archive>
<http://www.jxj.com/suppands/renenerg/companies/121.html>
Tim Shepheard-Walwyn , former class risk management Barclays Bank until 16th January 2002:
=====================================================================
Is it correct, that you invested in Afghan Development Company in Fall 1998?
Who was the executive in Fall 1998, who was in Afghanistan?
What did you exactly do in Fall 1998 in Afghanistan?
Helen Harris, TSI Telecommunication Services Inc. , since January 2002 GTCR Golden Rauner:
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of ENRON/Enron Online and TSI in Afghanistan and Pakistan since 1998?
When was it sure, that TSI has to be sold to GTCR Golden Rauner on December 10th, 2001?
Richard Cellar, UNOCAL Pakistan:
=====================================================================
When was the last time Richard Cheney meet UNOCAL?
When was the last time Henry Kissinger meet US-Ambassador in Pakistan, Robert Oakley?
Charlie Santos, former colleague of the UN-Sondermission in Afghanistan:
=====================================================================
When was the last time you meet anyone of the Taliban?
Hamed H. Amin , chief executive Consolidated Contractors International:
=====================================================================
What was exactly the purpose of CCI in Afghanistan since 1998?
Have you been in touch with any represantatives or executives of any of these companies:
UNOCAL, Halliburton, Carlyle, BinLadin Group Inc., Afghan Development Company, Barclays Bank, Telephone Systems International (TSI), SG Asia Project Finance, Northrop Grunman, ISI, CIA, Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC), Bristol-Myers Squibb, Americans for Affordable Electricity (ENRON is member)?
Have you been in touch with any represantatives of Barclays Bank?
SG Asia Project Finance, 15 QUEEN'S ROAD, HONG KONG
=====================================================================
Is your account in Hongkong in any way related to an Al-Quaeda account, what you didn't know before?
Deutschebank-Alex Brown
=====================================================================
Who was the investor who purchased 2,000 United Airlines (UAL) put option contracts between August 8th, 2001 and September 11th, 2001?
Did you or do you own any stocks of UA, AA, Merrill Lynch, Morgan Stanley, AXA Re (insurance) which owns 25% of American Airlines, and Munich Re.?
What can you say about 2,500 UA-contracts which were "split into 500 chunks each, directing each order to different U.S. exchanges around the country simultaneously." on August 10th, 2001?
Did you purchase UAL options in August 2001?
Is it correct that you purchased 4,744 put options (a speculation that the stock will go down) on United Air Lines stock as opposed to only 396 call options (speculation that the stock will go up) between September 6th and September 7th, 2001?
What was your intention of doing that?
What is your conection to Wally Kromgaard?
Is it correct that you or Wally Kromgaard purchase 4,516 put options on American Airlines as compared to 748 call options on September 10th, 2001?
What was the reason of Mayo Shattuck III resignment on September 15th?
Abdul Jalil,Taliban's deputy foreign minister, (if he is Still alive):
==================================================
When was the last time you meet any represantatives of the US-Government?
What was the purpose of these meetings?
Do you know Karl E. Inderfurth and State Department counterterrorism chief Michael Sheehan?
Do you know which US-Represantative told you in February 2001:
"Either you accept our offer of a carpet of gold, or we bury you under a carpet of bombs"?
When was the last time you have been in touch with this represantative?
Mowlawi Yar Mohammad Rahimi, former Talibans Communications Minister (if he is Still alive):
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of meetings with Telephone Systems International (TSI) ?
Did you ever meet any represantative of any of these companies:
UNOCAL, Halliburton, Carlyle, BinLadin Group Inc., Kissinger Associates Inc., Pentagon, Afghan Development Company, Barclays Bank, Telephone Systems International (TSI), Consolidated Contractors International,
SG Asia Project Finance,ISI, CIA, Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC)?
Is it correct that the Taliban was in possession of functionable Satellite Phones in June 2001?
Scott Ritter, former UN Inspecteur in Baghdad:
=====================================================================
Do you know Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani?
Do you know which persons he met between April 8th and April 11th, 2001?
What was the purpose of monitoring Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani?
Stanislav Gross, Czech interior minister:
=====================================================================
Who told you that Mohammad Atta met Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Samir al-Ani?
Can you explain, why Mohammad Atta was able to hire a car on April 11th in Florida,if he still was on a jetleg?
What do you know about an attack on Radio Free Europe's office?
Why did you and Prime Minister Milos Zeman later change the confirmation about that meeting?
Kent Kresa, Chairman of Northrop Grunman,
Ollie Boileau, COO Northrop Grunman Saratoga, WY:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that the Global Hawk technology was able to remote control one or more unmanned planes in 1999 for 27 hours?
Is it correct that you use or used Global Hawk technology in the war in Afghanistan since October 2001?
What is the purpose of unmanned technology?
Are you in contact with any engineers of Boeing?
Did you ever build in Global Hawk technology in a commercial airplane?
Tommy Franks, Commander in chief of Central Command,
Marine Lt. Gen. Michael P. DeLong
=============================================
Is it correct that two U.S. carrier battle groups arrived on station in the Gulf of Arabia just off the Pakistani coast before September 11th?
Is it also correct that at the same time, some 17,000 U.S. troops join more than 23,000 NATO troops in Egypt for Operation 'Bright Star.'?
What was the purpose of both of these operations?
To Tommy Franks only:
When did you learn, that you will start to use Thermobarics in ToraBora?
Do you know if they had been tested on December 12th in Nevada?
Who told you that Bin Laden might hide in ToraBora?
Is it correct that the main purpose of Thermobarics is to destroy buried bio and chemical stocks?
Do you know if Thermobarics have been developed for the purpose to use them one day in Iraque?
When was the first time you used Thermobarics?
Was it before or after the announcement of the end of ABM Treaty (December 11th)?
When did the US Military decide to use B61-11 which is the " nuclear version" of its "conventional" BLU-113 counterpart?
Why did the Pentagon ignore that the Taliban established a new party in Pakistan
On December 10th, 2oo1 called KFJ?
Bill Clinton:
=====================================================================
Why did you abort an attack on Bin Laden in October 1999?
Who was responsible for that operation?
Why did this person put that operation on hold?
General Pervez Musharraf, Pakistan:
=====================================================================
Why did you halt a covert operation to attack Bin Laden in October 1999?
Richard Reid:
=====================================================================
Who hired you to threaten a passenger plane in Paris?
Who did you send an email in Pakistan?
Have you ever been in touch with any represantatives of the ISI or CIA?
Do you know the difference between an explosive and a detonator?
How many ounces you had in your shoes?
What size are your shoes?
Who build or prepared your shoes?
John Walker Lindh:
=====================================================================
Have you ever been in touch with the CIA?
Did you ever work for the CIA?
Who arrested you in 2001?
Why didn't you escape in a tumult in October 2001 nearby Masar-e-Sharif?
Who hired your lawyer Richard Brohanan?
Who paid your lawyer Richard Brohanan?
Can you imagine why you need not to go to Guantanamo Bay?
Dick Cheney, Vice President and former CEO of Halliburton
======================================================
When did you stop working for Halliburton?
Are you still in possession of any Halliburton Stocks?
Are you still in contact with Halliburton?
Is it correct that Halliburton was invited to an oil conference in May 2002?
Do you know since which date that was planned?
Did you have any influence about contracts of Halliburton with the Pentagon?
Are you in contact with any represantatives of any of these companies or institutions:
UNOCAL, Halliburton, Carlyle, CDC, Department of Health and Human Services (HHS),BAYER, BioPort, BinLadin Group Inc., Kissinger Associates Inc., Pentagon, Acambis (former OraVax), DeutscheBank Alex Brown, Afghan Development Company, Barclays Bank, Telephone Systems International (TSI) , Consolidated Contractors International, SG Asia Project Finance, Northrop Grunman, ISI, CIA, American Airlines, United Airlines, Caspian Pipeline Consortium (CPC), Kevin Ingram, Ft. Detrick, MD, Battelle Memorial Institute (and various other US-Labs), General Motors (owned by ENRON), Bristol-Myers Squibb, Americans for Affordable Electricity (ENRON is member), if so what's the purpose?
What exactly did you decide on September 11th?
Did you speak with any Air Force Commander especially Lt. Gen. Charles F. Wald on that day?
When did you inform the president about the hijacked airplanes on September 11th?
Who called the White House on September 11th at 9:30 PM about a possible threat?
Why was no air security at the White House or the Pentagon at 9:30 PM?
When or who did give the ok to evacuate the White House at 9:45 PM?
What was the purpose of a meeting with Indian opposition leader Sonia Gandhi last June 2002 about a multimillion-dollar debt owed to Enron from a major energy project in Indian Power Plants?
When was the last time you spoke with anyone from ENRON?
What was the role of Colin Powell?
Colin Powell, Secretary of State
=====================================================================
Who decided to give you $43 million in aid to the Taliban regime in May 2001?
Do you know, that the Production of opium in Afghanistan fell from 3276 tonnes in 2000 to 185 tonnes in 2001?
What was the purpose of your decision to treat the Taliban prisoners as War Prisoners?
Is this decision in any way related to the media reports only 2 days earlier that you have been involved in negotiations with Indian Power Plants?
What was the purpose of a short trip to Latin America on September 11th?
Who decided that you have to fly to Latin America on that day?
Can you imagine, why someone plotted a threat on you in Afghanistan on January 17th, 2002 as Nesweek reported?
What was the purpose of a meeting with India's foreign minister last April 6, 2001?
Did Enron or Dick Cheney ask for your help at ENRON, who was trying to collect a $64 million debt on an Indian plant project?
Thomas White, Secretary of the Army
=====================================================================
Are you still in contact with ENRON and did this at anytime influence your decisions at the army?
Do you still own ENRON stocks?
Delmart Edward Joseph Michael Vreeland II, former US Navy intelligence:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you warned the Canadian Intelligence in May 2001 about a possible terrorist attacks on New York and the Pentagon?
Is it correct that you wrote that down in an envelope in a prison in Toronto, Canada?
Where did you get your information?
Who did you give that envelope?
Why you came into jail?
Philip Lumsden, Nicholas Hart, Karl Gebhard Jaeger, Andrew Nunn, Jeremy Burgess, all BinLadin Group:
==============================================
Is it correct that you own the domain SAUDI-BINLADIN-GROUP.COM?
Is it correct that you created that domain on September 11th, 2000?
Who paid for that domain?
Is it correct that you own percentages of Iridium Satellites?
Can you tell us since which date you stopped the contact with any relative of the Bush family?
George H.W. Bush, Former President of the United States:
=====================================================================
When was the last time you travelled to Saudi Arabia on behalf of the privately owned Carlyle Group, the 11th largest defense contractor in the U.S.?
What was the purpose of that meeting?
At which time you resigned from Carlyle Group?
Are you still in touch with any of their represantatives?
Stephen Lander , Director MI5?
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you monitored a phone conversation between Zacarias Moussaoui and Richard Reid in December 2000?
What exactly did you tell any represantative of the CIA about Zacarias Moussaoui?
Why did you stop monitoring Djamel Beghal, member of Takfir-wal-Hijra (financed by Osama bin Laden) in August 2001?

Henry George, Training Center Manager, SimCenter Inc.:
=====================================================================
At which time Mohammad Atta did train on a flight simulator?
Do you know if he ever left the United States in between and came back?
Is it correct that your classes start every year in February, April and November?
Can you imagine why Mohammad Atta decided to learn at Opa Locka, which is a famous hub of 6 Navy training bases and include government partners like U.S. Coast Guard Air Station, Police (Miami-Dade) Aviation Unit,?
Can you imagine why he was there though Mohammad Atta was searched by the police for driving without a license and violating his visa?
Chris McArthur, Airport Manager Miami International Airport Opa-locka:
=====================================================================
Which Federal Aviation Administration official placed an angry call on Dec. 27 because of an incident of Mohammad Atta and Marwan al-Shehhi?
Why was the investigation of that incident cancelled?
Who cancelled it?
Robert McFarlane, former national security adviser in the Reagan administration:
=====================================================================
Is it correct , that Abdul Haq, the former mujahedin leader (executed in sep/oct 2001 by Taliban) decided in Winter 2000 to attack the Taliban?
Do you know Peter Tomsen?
When was the last time you had been in touch with any of these mentioned persons?
Mullah Omar (if able to capture him)
=====================================================================
Is it correct, that the Production of opium in Afghanistan fell from 3276 tonnes in 2000 to 185 tonnes in 2001?

Al-Zawahiri (if able to capture him)
=====================================================
Is it correct that you visited Osama Bin laden in July 2001 in an american hospital in Dubai?
Do you know a Larry Stevens?
Bernard Koval, CEO American Hospital
=====================================================================
Is it correct that Osama Bin laden arrived on 4th July, 2001 on a flight from Qetta, Pakistan in your hospital?
Is it true, that he was at your hospital between 4th and 11th July 2001?
Did you ever speak with Doctor Terry Callaway about that visit?
Why did you change your statements that this story is not true and later that you "asked around"?
Can you tell us something about the difference between Continuous Ambulatory Peritoneal Dialysis and Continuous Cycling Peritoneal Dialysis?
Do you know a Larry Stevens?
Can you explain, why Richard Labeviere, a serious author, who released the book "Terror Dollars" about illegal Al-Quaeda accounts wrote this story about Osama Bin Ladens kidney operation?
President George Bush:
=====================================================================
When exactly did you learn about the first crash into the WTC?
Can you explain us, how you have been able to see that on TV?
Why didn't you interrupt your meeting at that school when you learned about the first plane crash into the WTC, an important national symbol?
Did you ever wonder how Bin Laden was able to follow the first plane crash live on the radio?
What do you think, which radio station he was listening to?
Can you explain the odd coincidence why someone found Bin Ladens Home Video only two weeks after it was produced?
Why you decided to release Bin Ladens Home Video?
What is the current purpose of the Western Hemisphere Institute for Security Cooperation (WHISC) in Fort Benning, Georgia, where terrorists have been trained for undercover agents in South America?
You stated in 2001, "if any government sponsors the outlaws and killers of innocents they have become outlaws and murderers themselves". What do you think about this sentence now if you think of Fort Benning?
What is the role of Zalmay Khalilzad (former UNOCAL) in the National Security Council ?
What is the current role of Zalmay Khalilzad (former UNOCAL) in Afghanistan?
Can you explain us the incident with the Pretzel again?
When was your last contact with anyone from ENRON?
Why was China able to admit to the World Trade Organization quickly on
September 13th, after 15 years of unsuccessful attempts?
Why did you postpone to release Ronald Reagans records?
What do you think of the idea to investigate the CIA because of many mistakes?
Do you agree with Senator John McCain, Senator Joseph I. Lieberman,
Porter J. Goss, former C.I.A. clandestine case officer and a Florida Republican, Senator Richard C. Shelby of Alabama and Ron Paul, US Congreessman, who wants to have an examination and said "Secret government is winning out over open government"?
Jeb Bush:
=====================================================================
Why did you declare Martial Law In florida on September 7th, 2001?

Zalmay Khalilzad, former UNOCAL:
=====================================================================
What is your current role in Afghanistan?
Are you still in contact with any represantatives of UNOCAL?
George Robertson, Secretary General, NATO
Mohammed Nashashibi, Former Roving Ambassador of the Arab League; Finance Minister for Palestine Authority
Kenneth S. Dam, Deputy Secretary designate at US Department of the Treasury, Council on Foreign Relations,
Daniel L. Vasella, Chairman & C.E.O., Novartis AG (Pharmaceuticals)
=====================================================
What exactly did you discuss on the Bilderberg meeting last year in May 2001?
Tony Blair, British Prime Minister:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that 25,000 British troops and the largest British Armada since the Falkland Islands War, part of Operation 'Essential Harvest,' planned to be pre-position in Oman, the closest point on the Arabian Peninsula to Pakistan before September 11th, 2001.
Is it correct that these troops had been underway before September 11th, 2001?
At which time after September 11th did you exactly start to put SIS-Special Forces in Afghanistan?
Why?
Dr.August Hanning , President BND (Bundesnachrichtendienst Germany)
=====================================================================
At which time did you inform the CIA, that "Middle Eastern terrorists are 'planning to hijack commercial aircraft ?"
What was their reaction?
Is it correct, that you allowed an iranian prisoner in Hamburg to call the CIA in Summer 2001 about an attack on America?
What was their reaction?
Joanne Solic , Owner Bimini Motel, Hollywood
=====================================================================
At which time in 1999 was Waleed Alshehri registered at your address?
Can you explain, why he was the same time registered Boynton Beach hotel as well?
Tayseer Allouni , Kabul correspondent Al-Jazeera:
=====================================================================
At which time did you receive your first video from Bin Laden?
Can you explain why the lights on that first video on October 7th 2001, the day of the retaliation, looked like it was recorded in the morning?
Do you know another homevideo of Bin Laden from June 2001, in which he praised an attack?
Did you know that Bin Laden was in an american hospital in Dubai in July 2001?
What's your personal explanation that General Mahmud resigned on the same
Day, when the retaliation started?
Kevin Ingram, former Deutschebank:
=====================================================================
What was the main purpose of your trades of nuclear weapons with Pakistan?
Do you know Wally Kromgaard?
Valrie Williams , housekeeper Homing Inn on Federal Highway in Boynton Beach
=====================================================================
Do you know, which two men Waleed M Al Shehri met in your motel between June 21 to July 26, 2001 in Room B-308
Tom Simmons (former U.S. Ambassador to Pakistan), Karl Inderfurth (former Assistant Secretary of State for South Asian affairs) and Lee Coldren (former State Department expert on South Asia):
=====================================================
Is it correct that you decided or said on a meeting in July 2001, that you planned an attack on the Taliban in October 2001?

Ms Barbara Bodine, US ambassador to Yemen:
=========================================================
Why didn't you allow John O'Neill to investigate Al-Quaeda accounts in July 2001?
Vladimir Putin, Russian President
=====================================================================
When did you warn the CIA about a possible terrorist attack and what was their reaction?
Gloria Irish
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you own an unit 1504 at the Delray Racquet Club, 755 Dotterel?
Did you rent that property to Hamza Alghamdi in August 2001?
Can you explain, why the media didn't report much about a connection of the Sun-Sentinel and the hijackers?
Can you imagine, why it first looked that the hijackers had anything to do with the anthrax attacks?
Can you imagine,why this connection or coincidence never appeared in the media again?
What was the connection between your husband Michael Irish (SunSentinel) and Bob Stevens (who died from Anthrax)?
Christina Rocca, the director of Asian affairs at the State Department
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of your meeting with the Taliban ambassador Mollah Abdul Salam Zaeef in Islamabad in August 2001?
Why did you oversee the delivery of Stinger missiles in the 80s to Afghan mujaheddin?
Walid Arkeh, Seminole County jail:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you informed the FBI in August 2001 about an attack on America?
What was the reaction of the FBI?
Dr. Jeffrey Starr, U.S. department of defense official
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of your visit in Tajikistan in January 2001?
Jean-Claude Cousseran, Director DGSE , French Secret Service:
=======================================================
At which time did you inform the CIA about terrorist attacks on America?
What was their reaction?
What can you tell us about the monitoring of Djamel Beghal, member of Takfir-wal-Hijra (financed by Osama bin Laden) and Kamel Daoudi?
Did you ever inform the CIA about that and at which time?
Italian Deputy Prime Minister Gianfranco Fini Mr Fini:
=====================================================================
At which time did you inform the CIA about a possible attack on the american president "with the use of an airplane"?
What was their reaction?
President Mubarak, Egypt
=====================================================================
At which time did you inform the CIA about a possible attack on america with an "airplane stuffed with explosives"?
What was their reaction?
Efraim Halevy , Director of Mossad since 1998 (unconfirmed)
=====================================================================
At which time did you inform the CIA about a possible attack with "200 terrorists" on america?
What was their reaction?
Is it correct that you warned Ariel Sharon not to travel to New York on September 11th to speak
on a festival?
Mr Loxley Banks, Director Radio Cayman Islands =====================================================================
Is it true, that a caller to one of your radio talk shows between September 3rd and 10th, 2001 gave several warnings of an imminent attack on the U.S.A?
NOTE: The Cayman Islands has six local radio stations: Government-owned Radio Cayman, which is heard throughout the three islands; Z-99 FM; Heaven 97 Christian radio; Vibe 98.9; Ocean 95.5 and ICCI-FM, based at the International College of the Cayman Islands and staffed by Journalism student volunteers
Salman Rushdie
=====================================================================
Is it correct, as London Times reported, that someone of the FAA warned you not to travel to the United States on September 3rd?
If so, who was it?
Harry's Bar at the Helmsley Hotel in Manhattan (East 42nd Street)
=====================================================================
Do you know if the FBI investigated, which two men met Mohamed Atta and Marwan Al-Shehhi in your bar on September 8th, 2001?
Can you maybe say, who the two men had been?
Abdullah Abdullah, Northern Alliance:
=====================================================================
Who do you think killed Commander Ahmad Shah Massoud on September 9th, 2001?
At which time and why did you decide to attack Kabul on September 11th at 5:30 PM?
When did you decide to invade Masar-i-Scharif , before September 22nd?
Is it correct that the CIA helped you to provoke a tumult?
Did you ever meet John Walker Singh?
Major John Kenny, Commander Wright Patterson Air Base, Dayton
========================================================
Why have you been on high alert on September 1oth?
Is it true that you informed any other companies in Dayton to shutdown their offices?
Colonel William M. Dietrick , Commander Defense Language Institute in Garrison, Monterey
========================================================
Why have you been on high alert on September 1oth?
Kenneth (Ken) Weinbrecht, President SAMS
=====================================================================
Is it correct that one of your executives say on September 10th, 2001, 'Wildcard. Ruthless and cunning. Has capability to target US forces and make it look like a Palestinian/Arab act.'"
Jean-Louis Bruguiere, anti-terrorism Judge France:
=====================================================================
Did you inform the CIA on September 1oth about your investigation about a possible terrorist attack?
If so, what was their reaction?
Portland, Maine motel (unidentified):
=====================================================================
Do you know, why Atta and hijacker Abdulaziz Alomari checked in a motel on September 10th?
Elisa Dozono , Media Contact Portland, Airport:
=====================================================================
Why was your airport, due to some eye-witnesses, with all respect, in full charge of more military officials and soldiers than usual, since weeks before September 11th, 2001?
Mayor Brown, LA:
=====================================================================
Is it correct, as San Francisco Chronicle reported,that you have been warned to be "cautious in your travel" in the night of September 10th?
Who informed you?
Alex Diamandis, vice president of sales and marketing Odigo:
=====================================================================
Is it correct, that you get a warning on your messenger service about a possible attack on America on September 11th, 2001?
At which time?
Daniel P. Burnham, Chairman of the Board of Directors Raytheon:
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of travel of Kenneth Waldie, Stanley Hall, Herbert Homer and Peter Gay on September 11th?
Can you confirm that Global Hawk technology can be used for at least 27 hours?
Do you know of any use of Global Hawk technology in commercial airplanes?
Danielle O'Brien, air traffic controller
=====================================================================
At which time did you inform any other air traffic control center about a fast plane southwest of Dulles after you saw it at 8:18, September 11th and who was it?
What happened after you informed the other air traffic control center?
Dr. James G. Roche, Secretary of the Air Force:
============================================
Why didn't you try to reach the airplanes in NYC (7 minutes time for McGuire AFB in New Jersey ) and at the Pentagon (10 minutes time)?
Did you ever try to shutdown the plane in Pennsylvannia?
Can you explain, why magazines of that plane have been found many miles away from the crash?
Andrews AFB is 13 miles away, You had one hour and fifteen minutes to respond to the plane that ended up hitting the Pentagon-what happened during that time?
Can you explain why many ear- and eye witnesses, including workers of the road construction company New Enterpise saw or heard F-16s next to the Pennsylvannia machine?
Why did President Bush said only one week later that he tried to shutdown that plane?
Who gave that decision?
Why did George Bush leaft Barksdale Air Force Base aboard Air Force One and flew to an Air Force base in Nebraska on 1:48 PM on September 11th, 2001 and returned to Washington at 4:30 PM?
What exactly did Donald Rumsfeld do that day until he arrived at the Pentagon at around 3:55 PM?
How did you know at 5:30 PM on September 11th, that the plane in Pennsylvannia could have been headed for one of three possible targets:
Camp David, the White House or the U.S. Capitol building?
Can you explain why early media reports told us that no squadrons of combat-ready fighter jets have been at Andrews and later changed their reports that they haven't been on high alert only?
Why was Air Force Lt. Col. Vic Warzinski, another Pentagon spokesman so sure on September 11th, that aircraft was coming your way?
What did the D.C. Air National Guard in Washington do on September 11th?
Can you explain, what those 3 fighters did do from 9:40AM until 9:55AM when they finally turned towards Flight 93 and were 60 miles out at 10:06am?
Can you explain, why Air Traffic Controllers in a Nashua Telegraph article did report an F-16 was circling Flight 93 and was in visual range at the time of crash?
Can you confirm a witness report, that National Guard F-16's have been at Hancock field in Syracuse NY in the air early that morning before 9AM?
How could the hijackers disable the defense systems?
Maj. Gen. Richard A. Mentemeyer Commander, 305th Air Mobility Wing, McGuire Air Force Base, New Jersey
=====================================================================
What was the official reason that none of your fighters did reach the 2nd hijacker plane in New York in time,
Which would have been possible in 7 minutes after 8:48 AM on September 11th, 2001?
Lieutenant Colonel Brad O. Buchanan, commander of the 459th Aircraft Generation Squadron, Andrews AFB
=====================================================================
Due to your own homepage, Andrews AFB is only 10 miles away from Washington DC.
What was the official reason that none of your fighters did reach the hijacker plane which crashed into the Pentagon, in time?
Col. Ken McClellan, Air Force spokesman:
=========================================================
Is it correct, that as you said on September 11th, that Mohammad Atta had once attended the International Officer's School at Maxwell/Gunter Air Force Base in Montgomery, also due to some eye-witnesses?
What did he do there?
Why did you later deny that report?
Why did you decide not to shutdown ECHELON base Bad Aibling in Germany as planned for 2002?
What was the official reason that none of any Air Force fighters did reach the hijackers plane in time?
What can you tell us about many eye- and witnesses who think that the machine in Pennsylvannia was shut down?
What could be the scientific explanation, that an official magazine of the Pennsylvannia airplane wasn't found right at the debris, but many miles away?
Jack Kelly, idefense.com
========================================================
Why did you inform the media (USA Today) only 12 minutes after the first crash on the WTC (8:48AM), that terror groups behind Web encryption might have been responsible for that crash?
And why you have been so sure before the second crash which happened at 9:03 PM?
Is it correct that you served with the U.S. government where you managed several significant programs for the information warfare and intelligence communities?
Joseph J. Esposito, Chief of Department NYPD:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you tried to contact the Pentagon at 9:06 AM on September 11th?
What was their reaction?
General Elwood "Pete" Quesada, Leader of FAA:
=====================================================================
Why didn't you inform President Bush between 8:15 and 9:05 about four simultaneously hijacked planes?
Who did you inform and what was their reaction?
Nicholas Scoppetta , new commissioner of FDNY since December 30th, 2001?
=====================================================================
Can you tell us something about the latest reports about the destruction on the Twin Towers?
Can you explain why many ear- and eyewitnesses recognised more than two explosions in the WTC?
Can you explain why both Twin Towers and Building 7 collapsed in that way?
Can you explain why a gas tank was in Building 7?
Can you explain why no passengers have been in the subway under the WTC?
Can you explain why no guard was at the gold reservoir under the WTC?
Dr. Jeffrey P. Koplan, Director CDC:
=====================================================================
Why did you prepare,as CNN reported emergency-response teams on September 11th at 11:16 PM?
John R. Samuel , Vice President American Airlines,
Rono Dutta's , President United Airlines:
=====================================================================
Why none of the 19 hijackers did appear on the official passenger lists you gave out on September 11th to CNN?
Why did you remove your own lists on your websites only 2, 3 days later?
Former afghan Minister of Mining and Industries (if he's still alive)
==============================================
What was the purpose of signing a memorandum of understanding with the Chinese economic and technical cooperation delegation on September 11th, 2001?
Frank Sesno, CNN Washington Bureau Chief:
=====================================================================
Which government official told you there was an open microphone on one of the hijacked planes and that sounds of discussion and "duress" were heard?
Niaz Niak, former Pakistani Foreign Secretary:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you said in mid July 2001, that the USA have planned military action against Osama Bin Laden and the Taliban?
Hameed Gul, retired Pakistani general of Pakistan's Inter Services Intelligence:
=====================================================================
Is it correct that you said, a secret service have been involved in the attack on America and which one do you think?
Tommy Thompson, The Secretary of the Department of Health and Human Services
=====================================================================
Why did you and other Bush cabinet members meet secretly (that is, illegally) with officials of the Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA) to develop plans for their Emergency Preparedness Task Force in October 2001?
Why did you decide on October 25th, 2001 to ask the Congress for another $500 million to produce enough of Acambis's smallpox vaccine?
Jean Marie Malecki , Director Palm Beach County Health Department
=====================================================================
Why did it take 4.5 hours until you pick up he phone for employees of the
AMI-Building, Boca Raton, which editor Bob Stevens had anthrax?
Why did it take 2 days until you visited that building again?
Walter Gilbert, Director Myriad Genetics
=====================================================================
Did you ever get official permissions of all relatives of the World Trade Center
to examine the DNA of their dead relatives?
Rudy Guilani:
=====================================================================
Why was the rubble of the Twin Towers sold to India for recycling and other parts to China? Who gave that decision?
Tamas Hevizi, President and Chief Executive Officer, Zero-Knowledge Systems
=====================================================================
Why did you decide to stop your anonymous Program and PGP-Encryption on October 6th?
Did anyone threaten you to do that?
Wendy Chamberlain, U.S. Ambassador
=====================================================================
What was the purpose of the telephone call on October 10th, 2001 to
Pakistani oil minister?
Why you have been so sure that day, that a previously abandoned Unocal pipeline from Turkmenistan, across Afghanistan, to the Pakistani coast, for the purpose of selling oil and gas to China, is now back on the table in view of recent geopolitical developments?
C. Paul Robinson, President and Director, Sandia National Laboratories
=====================================================================
Is it correct, that Sandia increased their weapon productions already in mid 2001?
Is it correct that you promoted new nuclear weapons in 2001,as in one of your statements: "It also seemed abundantly clear that any use of nuclear weapons is, and always will be, strategic"?
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$155.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network