top
East Bay
East Bay
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Portland officials move to address housing crisis while Oakland claims no crisis exists

by M Hennings
Portland approves housing emergency plan - while Oakland's Housing Director Rachel Flynn denies there is an issue, and mayor Libby Schaaf attempts to nominate an employee of an 'eviction bootcamp' attorney to represent tenants at the Oakland Rent Board
Other cities across the country are acknowledging and ACTING to address the affordability crisis that is affecting many urban areas.

Last week, Portland Oregon approved a housing emergency plan, including offering 60 million dollars for AFFORDABLE housing projects.
http://portlandtribune.com/pt/9-news/275670-151397-mayor-council-move-to-combat-housing-crisis

Meanwhile Oakland officials attempted to violate the California Surplus Land Act
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/SevenDays/archives/2015/07/16/breaking-news-oakland-finally-obeys-law-offers-publicly-owned-east-12th-st-land-to-affordable-housing-developers

Portland approves housing 'emergency' plan, while Oakland officials sit on their hands (or claim that the affordability crisis doesn't exist)

Back in July 2015 - The East Bay Express reported that City of Oakland was 'eyeballing' the proposed solutions in:
"A Roadmap Toward Equity: Housing Solutions for Oakland, California"
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/oakland/will-oakland-protect-and-expand-affordable-housing/Content?oid=4434133

Oakland, California, faces a serious shortage of affordable housing. Commissioned by the Oakland City Council, A Roadmap Toward Equity analyzes the depth of the problem and presents more than a dozen policy solutions for preventing displacement, increasing the stock of affordable housing, and improving housing habitability for all Oakland residents.

Erica Derryck, spokesperson for Mayor Libby Schaaf, said that the mayor's office supports the road map and is already working to implement some of the strategies outlined in it

President Lynette Gibson McElhaney, who is also a member of the CED committee, wrote in an email to the Express that she intends to organize a fall summit to discuss the road map, and that the full city council will consider the road map on September 30.


And here we are in October, and from what I can tell, the plans to implement anything is bullshit. Oakland instead appears to be backpedaling,:

Oakland's director of planning and building: There is no affordable housing crisis!

October 6, 2015 -
Oakland's Director of Planning and Building Rachel Flynn reportedly told a conference of real estate developers in San Francisco yesterday that Oakland's residents are NOT facing an affordable housing crisis.
http://www.eastbayexpress.com/SevenDays/archives/2015/10/07/oaklands-top-housing-official-there-is-no-affordable-housing-crisis

Oakland's Mayor nominates the associate of 'eviction bootcamp' to the Oakland Rent Board
October 9, 2015 -
Oakland's Mayor Libby Schaaf nominates an associate of a landlord's atty who specializes in evicting tenants - to the Oakland Rent Board
After the East Bay Express published an article about the nomination and the connection, Libby Schaaf withdrew her support.

http://www.eastbayexpress.com/SevenDays/archives/2015/10/09/mayor-schaaf-nominates-associate-of-eviction-specialist-to-oakland-rent-control-board


Oakland's housing director is pretty clear that there is zero intent to protect affordable housing for the most vulnerable citizens. Nor is there any intent to ensure the existing housing stock is safe, and compliant with CA Housing Laws

See:
October 08, 2015 SF Business Times Article: Downtown Oakland SRO getting upgrades to attract upscale tenants

“SROs are "a way the private market provides naturally affordable housing,” said Rachel Flynn, Oakland’s planning director. “That’s always a problem when the private market decides it wants to shift clientele. We really can’t control what they do with their private property as long as they comport with displacement laws.” - Oakland's Director of Planning and Building Rachel Flynn

See Oakland Local: March 2015
There is very little affordable housing available for low-income Oakland seniors,
http://oaklandlocal.com/2015/03/affordable-housing-out-of-reach-for-many-low-income-oakland-seniors/


Oakland officials: When are you going to step up and protect the working class renters that make up the majority of OAKLAND?

Oakland renters: It's time to stand up and make yourself heard. Contact Libby Schaaf. Contact your city councilperson, and tell them Oakland residents DESERVE safe and affordable housing.

If our Mayor and Oakland's Housing Director are incapable of acknowledging this crisis, it's time to replace them with people who give a damn.
The entire bay area is experiencing an affordable housing crisis, and it is beyond time for action.
Contact your elected official TODAY and tell them that it is PAST TIME for action.

Please call or email your council member now, and use the following script (contact info below):
Dear Mayor/Councilmember/City Administrator:

I am a RENTER in Oakland.
As you learned at a recent City Council Meeting, many Oakland residents are experiencing shockingly high increases in their rents, while others have been recently displaced or facing the prospect of being pushed out of Oakland because of the increasingly expensive housing market.

Recent reports show that Oakland's rents and home prices have increased faster than virtually any city in the nation. Oakland's median rent is now $2,650, according to Zillow. Oakland's median household income is $52,583, according to the US Census. Thus the median household must spend 60 percent of its total income to rent the median home, which is twice the level that is considered affordable.

Although Oakland's rent control program has helped some tenants to remain in affordable housing, however much of that housing stock has serious habitability issues, which continues to get worse as Oakland Building Services fails to proactively inspect apartment buildings or enforce housing code violations.

The Housing, Health, and Habitability in Oakland Executive Summary Fact Sheet for 2011-2012 details the serious habitability issues that face almost ONE-THIRD of tenants who seek assistance from Tenant Services organizations were currently facing in Oakland rental housing. http://www.acphd.org/media/315757/healthyhousing_factsheet.pdf

In 2012 and in response to the Alameda County Grand Jury Investigation of the City of Oakland Building Services Department, the City of Oakland Office of Planning, Building & Neighborhood Preservation submitted a "Proposed Program Design for Proactive Code Enforcement Operations" http://www2.oaklandnet.com/oakca/groups/ceda/documents/report/oak033410.pdf

It is now 2015, and many of these proposals have yet to see the light of day, most importantly: III. Multiple-Family Substandard
Properties sections A and B - a proactive approach to rental housing inspections.

Oakland's deteriorated multi-family housing stock and the lack of proactive code enforcement makes for a lucrative 'fix and flip' market for real estate investors, and a nightmare for tenants. Owners of affordable (but substandard) multi-family properties are pressured to sell, and tenants are pushed out. Long overdue repairs are called 'improvements' and the cost is passed down to the tenants.

Tenants can presumably go to Oakland's rent board to contest rent increases, but when there is no proactive building inspection, the burden of proving what is and isn't 'deferred maintenance'' is placed on the tenant. Many rent board hearings are not simple events, and very few landlords can afford to pay an attorney for representation.

Many other cities have acknowledged that urban areas are experiencing a housing crisis, and that simply building more luxury dwellings will not do anything to alleviate the skyrocketing rents and displacement.

Portland, Oregon - a city that is not known for high rents was in the news last week when their City Council and Mayor approved a housing emergency plan, putting aside funds for affordable housing and offering incentives while proposing new fees on developers to help pay for affordable housing. They are providing 650 additional shelter spaces for women and those with disabilities.

Now that the Council has had time to review and discuss 'A Roadmap Toward Equity: Housing Solutions for Oakland, California, I am eager to get a resolution on the exorbitant rents being charged by new landlords attempting to cash in on Oakland's housing market, and how you propose on protecting our existing affordable housing stock. Current Oakland residents deserve elected officials who ACT on this crisis, rather than sweeping it under the rug.

In partnership with other tenants across Oakland, California, I as a VOTER, fully expect that you are prepared to address this housing crisis immediately.

Your refusal to do so means that Oakland tenants - who from what I understand hold the majority of the voting power - may need to considering finding elected officials who are willing to stand up for their residents.

Thank you
[Your Name]
Mayor Libby Schaaf
(510) 238-3141 or officeofthemayor [at] oaklandnet.com or @libbyschaaf (twitter)
City Administrator: Sabrina Landreth
(510) 238-3301 or cityadministrator [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 1 – Dan Kalb
(510) 238-7001 or dkalb [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 2 – Abel J. Guillen
(510) 238-7002 or aguillen [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 3 – Lynette Gibson McElhaney (Council President)
(510) 238-7003 or President [at] Oaklandnet.com
Council District 4 – Annie Campbell Washington
(510) 238-7004 or ACampbellWashington [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 5 – Noel Gallo
(510) 238-7005 or ngallo [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 6 – Desley Brooks
(510) 238-7006 or dbrooks [at] oaklandnet.com
Council District 7 – Larry Reid
(510) 238-7007 or lreid [at] oaklandnet.com
Councilmember At Large – Rebecca Kaplan
(510) 238-7008 or atlarge [at] oaklandnet.com
Add Your Comments
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$75.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network