From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
Fri Sep 19 2014 (Updated 10/02/14)
BART Police Deputy Chief Faces Trial for Retaliation Against Indybay Reporter
“Be on the Look Out” Flyer Depicting Dave Id was Distributed to BART Police Officers
On September 22, former BART Police Deputy Chief Dan Hartwig will be called to account in federal court for his role in targeting and arresting independent journalist David Morse during a “No Justice No BART” protest at the Powell Street BART station three years ago. Morse was the only credentialed journalist who was handcuffed, arrested, and held in police custody for several hours, while other reporters with and without credentials were all released without citation from a police encirclement.
Plaintiff David Morse is a veteran journalist and long-time member of the San Francisco Bay Area Independent Media Center (Indybay). At the time of his arrest, Morse had published over 250 separate reports related to the killings of Oscar Grant and Charles Hill and “openly mocked and ridiculed the agency and its officers,” in the words of Magistrate Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley. “These declarations did not go unnoticed at BART,” Corley continued, ruling that the case can go forward to trial.
Judge Corley also noted that BART took the unusual step of ordering that a “Be on the Look Out” flyer depicting Morse be created and distributed to BART police officers prior to the protest on September 8, 2011. Police radio transmissions, depositions, and other evidence reveal the strong focus BART police had on Morse prior to and during the protest.
The trial is expected to last five days starting on Monday, September 22, with proceedings scheduled to occur from 8:30am to 2:30pm. The trial will be held in Courtroom “D” on the 16th floor of the US District Court in San Francisco with the Honorable Judge Scott Corley presiding.
UPDATE: Verdict in BART PD Trial, September 29: The jury in US District Court found that — despite BART police admitting across the board to reading countless Indybay articles by Dave Id which severely criticized BART police and named names, despite Deputy Chief Fairow ordering a flier be created identifying Dave Id as a subject for police focus during the 9/8/11 Powell Street station protest, despite BART police discussing arresting Dave Id at a planning meeting prior to the protest (even though all officers who testified said Dave Id had never committed a crime at a previous protest), despite BART police tracking Dave Id throughout the protest, and despite Deputy Chief Hartwig choosing Dave Id to be very first person arrested when all other journalists were released from a police kettle (many of whom lacked credentials and merely held cameras) — Deputy Chief Hartwig did not retaliate against Dave Id for his hundreds of critical reports on BART police. Dave Id and Indybay strongly disagree.
Read more | Legal documents
Previous Coverage: Federal Judge Rules That Indybay Journalist Can Sue BART Police For Retaliatory Arrest | Indybay Coverage of the Justice for Oscar Grant Movement
Previous Features Related to Indybay Reporters: NLG Obtains $1.17M and OPD Reforms for Injured Occupy Oakland Protesters and Journalists | Indybay Reporter Charged in 2011 Vacant Bank Occupation: Bradley Allen's Story | Indybay Journalist Wins Payment and UCB Agreement to Change Policies, Train Officers | All Charges Dismissed Against Indybay Photojournalists Bradley and Alex | ACLU-NC Submits Brief in Support of Indybay's Bradley Stuart Allen and Alex Darocy | Indybay Journalists Charged with Felony: Conspiracy to Make Media | Society of Professional Journalists Committee Scolds BART for Actions at Sept. 8th Protest | Indybay Reporter Files Supreme Court Appeal in Civil Rights Case | Indybay Reporter Files Federal Civil Rights Lawsuit Against UC Police | Indybay Journalist Denied the Right to Sue to Redress His Own False Arrest by SFPD in 2004 | Indybay Reporter Succeeds in Quashing UCPD Search Warrant | Reporter Josh Wolf Freed | Josh Wolf Jailed For Refusal to Hand Over Video of Protest | SF Grand Jury Targets G8 Protest And Independent Journalist
Plaintiff David Morse is a veteran journalist and long-time member of the San Francisco Bay Area Independent Media Center (Indybay). At the time of his arrest, Morse had published over 250 separate reports related to the killings of Oscar Grant and Charles Hill and “openly mocked and ridiculed the agency and its officers,” in the words of Magistrate Judge Jacqueline Scott Corley. “These declarations did not go unnoticed at BART,” Corley continued, ruling that the case can go forward to trial.
Judge Corley also noted that BART took the unusual step of ordering that a “Be on the Look Out” flyer depicting Morse be created and distributed to BART police officers prior to the protest on September 8, 2011. Police radio transmissions, depositions, and other evidence reveal the strong focus BART police had on Morse prior to and during the protest.
The trial is expected to last five days starting on Monday, September 22, with proceedings scheduled to occur from 8:30am to 2:30pm. The trial will be held in Courtroom “D” on the 16th floor of the US District Court in San Francisco with the Honorable Judge Scott Corley presiding.
UPDATE: Verdict in BART PD Trial, September 29: The jury in US District Court found that — despite BART police admitting across the board to reading countless Indybay articles by Dave Id which severely criticized BART police and named names, despite Deputy Chief Fairow ordering a flier be created identifying Dave Id as a subject for police focus during the 9/8/11 Powell Street station protest, despite BART police discussing arresting Dave Id at a planning meeting prior to the protest (even though all officers who testified said Dave Id had never committed a crime at a previous protest), despite BART police tracking Dave Id throughout the protest, and despite Deputy Chief Hartwig choosing Dave Id to be very first person arrested when all other journalists were released from a police kettle (many of whom lacked credentials and merely held cameras) — Deputy Chief Hartwig did not retaliate against Dave Id for his hundreds of critical reports on BART police. Dave Id and Indybay strongly disagree.
![pdf](/im/imc_pdf.gif)
Previous Coverage: Federal Judge Rules That Indybay Journalist Can Sue BART Police For Retaliatory Arrest | Indybay Coverage of the Justice for Oscar Grant Movement
Previous Features Related to Indybay Reporters: NLG Obtains $1.17M and OPD Reforms for Injured Occupy Oakland Protesters and Journalists | Indybay Reporter Charged in 2011 Vacant Bank Occupation: Bradley Allen's Story | Indybay Journalist Wins Payment and UCB Agreement to Change Policies, Train Officers | All Charges Dismissed Against Indybay Photojournalists Bradley and Alex | ACLU-NC Submits Brief in Support of Indybay's Bradley Stuart Allen and Alex Darocy | Indybay Journalists Charged with Felony: Conspiracy to Make Media | Society of Professional Journalists Committee Scolds BART for Actions at Sept. 8th Protest | Indybay Reporter Files Supreme Court Appeal in Civil Rights Case | Indybay Reporter Files Federal Civil Rights Lawsuit Against UC Police | Indybay Journalist Denied the Right to Sue to Redress His Own False Arrest by SFPD in 2004 | Indybay Reporter Succeeds in Quashing UCPD Search Warrant | Reporter Josh Wolf Freed | Josh Wolf Jailed For Refusal to Hand Over Video of Protest | SF Grand Jury Targets G8 Protest And Independent Journalist
2024-06-11
If Passed, Measure J Will Ban "Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations"
Front Page
| North Bay / Marin
| Government & Elections
| Animal Liberation2024-06-11
Activists Stand in Solidarity with Horses Who Lost Their Lives at Race Track
Front Page
| East Bay
| Animal Liberation2024-06-11
Two Years After Shireen Abu Akleh Was Killed, There Still Is No Justice
Front Page
| Anti-War
| Media Activism & Independent Media
| San Francisco
| International
| Palestine2024-06-11
Crisis Team Provides Students with Non-Police Response to Mental Health Crises
Front Page
| Police State & Prisons
| Health, Housing & Public Services
| Education & Student Activism
| California
| Santa Cruz Indymedia2024-06-11
Only a Couple of Thousand Adult Leatherback Turtles Remain in the Pacific Ocean
Front Page
| Environment & Forest Defense
| San Francisco
| Peninsula
| North Bay / Marin
| North Coast
| California
| Animal Liberation
| Santa Cruz Indymedia2024-05-25
Demonstrators Denounce Tech Giant's Contracts with Israeli Military
Front Page
| Anti-War
| Peninsula
| U.S.
| International
| Palestine2024-05-13
Actions Call on Biden to Declare a Climate Emergency and End Fossil Fuels
Front Page
| Environment & Forest Defense
| Global Justice & Anti-Capitalism
| Education & Student Activism
| San Francisco
| Peninsula
| California
| U.S.
| Palestine2024-05-08
Resistance to Deceptive Forest Service Measure Is Growing
Front Page
| Environment & Forest Defense
| Central Valley
| California
| U.S.2024-05-08
Regulators Fail to Protect Schoolchildren from Repeated Exposure to Dangerous Pesticides
Front Page
| Environment & Forest Defense
| Racial Justice
| Health, Housing & Public Services
| Labor & Workers
| Education & Student Activism
| Santa Cruz Indymedia2024-04-24
Across the Globe, Students Set Up Encampments in Solidarity with Palestinians
Front Page
| Police State & Prisons
| Anti-War
| Education & Student Activism
| Central Valley
| San Francisco
| South Bay
| East Bay
| Peninsula
| North Bay / Marin
| North Coast
| California
| U.S.
| International
| Palestine
| Santa Cruz Indymedia2024-04-09
Deal Described as One of the Most Significant Urban Land Back Victories in US History
Front Page
| Environment & Forest Defense
| Racial Justice
| East Bay
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network