From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature
FCC Hearing: Internet Freedom Under Attack (Pt. II)
RAGING GRANNIES THANK THE FCC for coming to the west coast in skit outside the hearing.
FCC commissioners Michael Copps and Jonathan Adelstein called for the agency to strengthen its power to prevent Comcast and its competitors from unfairly discriminating against select customers. Out of the five commissioners they are the only two Democrats. Both commissioners thanked the Raging Grannies for joining in the public voice for internet neutrality at the April 17, 2008 hearing. During the public comment period, not even ONE person came to the defense of ISPs.
FCC commissioners Michael Copps and Jonathan Adelstein called for the agency to strengthen its power to prevent Comcast and its competitors from unfairly discriminating against select customers. Out of the five commissioners they are the only two Democrats. Both commissioners thanked the Raging Grannies for joining in the public voice for internet neutrality at the April 17, 2008 hearing. During the public comment period, not even ONE person came to the defense of ISPs.
At issue: should we trust the phone and cable companies at their word that they will not block or slow down content or services that does not happen to be offered by their favorite content partners? Or, for that matter, by those broadband Internet access providers themselves?
In tests conducted late last year, The Associated Press proved that Comcast was throttling the broadband connection of subscribers who were sharing files over the Internet.
The Raging Grannies absolutely do NOT believe it will do to just “take big Telecom's word”. We testified on behalf of all internet users from all political spectrums.
One of the most interesting panel members who spoke in favor of network neutrality was Christian Coalition's Michele Combs. She argued that the cable companies would be happy to let the porn industry pay for access to consumers, whereas "grassroots" organizations like her own would be silenced. Raging Grannies Ruth and Gail congratulated Michele when we met up with her during the break and had photo (below) taken with her.
During the public comment period, "Tiny" Lisa Gray Garcia from Poor Magazine brought up the issue of the digital divide and how a tilted Web playing field would restrict access to Internet adoption among disenfranchised communities, including immigrant communities, who are starting to get online to speak out for their causes.
An eloquent Latina spoke with a translator for the needs of the Spanish-speaking community. When cut off after 90 seconds (the maximum time set per speaker) the crowd shouted, "Let her speak! Give her more time!" Clyde, the FCC moderator, hesitated at first until one of the Grannies shouted out, "This is California, and it's how we do it here!" Upon hearing this he relented and allowed an additional 90 seconds. The representative of the Latino community finished her statement and many in the audience cheered with "Si, se puede!"
As one blogger said: "No wonder Comcast didn't show up — public opinion was stacked against them!". All the big telecoms were invited to appear; not ONE came. The FCC announced that big telecom DID, however, suggest speakers for the panel. One George Ou, who is most certainly on the payroll of big telecom (we hear it's AT&T) was on the panel and was heckled with: "Who paid your way, George?" The FCC asked the entire panel shortly after that interjection if any of them were paid, even if just for travel expenses. Mr. Ou answered, "I drove myself here", avoiding the question as best he was able. Later in the day, one of the Grannies and George Ou got into heated discussion outside the hearing and things looked dicey until Granny defender Byrd Hale of KZSU told Ou, "Don't mess with the Raging Grannies if you know what's good for you," to which the Grannies added, "That's right, when you are at Stanford you are in Raging Granny territory."
More coverage here:
http://blogs.pcworld.com/staffblog/archives/006820.html
http://www.audioholics.com/news/industry-news/raging-grannies-urge-fcc-to-control-net-neutrality
More songs and chants from Granny performance in front of Dinkenspiel Hall:
Marchin' for Neutrality
tune: Saints Come Marchin' In
When we have net, neutrality
When we have net, neutrality
how I want to be in that number
When we have net, neutrality
**When corporate greed, no longer rules
**When no one can, block my email
CHANT: Listen Comcast, can you hear?
Internet Freedom
Is that clear?
We need Internet Freedom
Tune: God Bless America
We need the internet, It must be free
No more screening Or blocking
We are here to instruct the FCC
Say to Comcast, to Verizon
and to A T an-and T
Hands off the internet It must be FREE
Hands off the internet It must be Free
In tests conducted late last year, The Associated Press proved that Comcast was throttling the broadband connection of subscribers who were sharing files over the Internet.
The Raging Grannies absolutely do NOT believe it will do to just “take big Telecom's word”. We testified on behalf of all internet users from all political spectrums.
One of the most interesting panel members who spoke in favor of network neutrality was Christian Coalition's Michele Combs. She argued that the cable companies would be happy to let the porn industry pay for access to consumers, whereas "grassroots" organizations like her own would be silenced. Raging Grannies Ruth and Gail congratulated Michele when we met up with her during the break and had photo (below) taken with her.
During the public comment period, "Tiny" Lisa Gray Garcia from Poor Magazine brought up the issue of the digital divide and how a tilted Web playing field would restrict access to Internet adoption among disenfranchised communities, including immigrant communities, who are starting to get online to speak out for their causes.
An eloquent Latina spoke with a translator for the needs of the Spanish-speaking community. When cut off after 90 seconds (the maximum time set per speaker) the crowd shouted, "Let her speak! Give her more time!" Clyde, the FCC moderator, hesitated at first until one of the Grannies shouted out, "This is California, and it's how we do it here!" Upon hearing this he relented and allowed an additional 90 seconds. The representative of the Latino community finished her statement and many in the audience cheered with "Si, se puede!"
As one blogger said: "No wonder Comcast didn't show up — public opinion was stacked against them!". All the big telecoms were invited to appear; not ONE came. The FCC announced that big telecom DID, however, suggest speakers for the panel. One George Ou, who is most certainly on the payroll of big telecom (we hear it's AT&T) was on the panel and was heckled with: "Who paid your way, George?" The FCC asked the entire panel shortly after that interjection if any of them were paid, even if just for travel expenses. Mr. Ou answered, "I drove myself here", avoiding the question as best he was able. Later in the day, one of the Grannies and George Ou got into heated discussion outside the hearing and things looked dicey until Granny defender Byrd Hale of KZSU told Ou, "Don't mess with the Raging Grannies if you know what's good for you," to which the Grannies added, "That's right, when you are at Stanford you are in Raging Granny territory."
More coverage here:
http://blogs.pcworld.com/staffblog/archives/006820.html
http://www.audioholics.com/news/industry-news/raging-grannies-urge-fcc-to-control-net-neutrality
More songs and chants from Granny performance in front of Dinkenspiel Hall:
Marchin' for Neutrality
tune: Saints Come Marchin' In
When we have net, neutrality
When we have net, neutrality
how I want to be in that number
When we have net, neutrality
**When corporate greed, no longer rules
**When no one can, block my email
CHANT: Listen Comcast, can you hear?
Internet Freedom
Is that clear?
We need Internet Freedom
Tune: God Bless America
We need the internet, It must be free
No more screening Or blocking
We are here to instruct the FCC
Say to Comcast, to Verizon
and to A T an-and T
Hands off the internet It must be FREE
Hands off the internet It must be Free
For more information:
http://www.RagingGrannies.com
Add Your Comments
Comments
(Hide Comments)
First of all, you're not even quoting me correctly. I said I didn't get paid by anyone AND I drove their with Richard Bennett (Network Architect who also doesn't get paid). I decided to commute with Richard and save some gasoline and parking fees.
Marvin Ammori of Free Press likes to libel Richard Bennett as a Comcast shill when the only money flowing between Comcast and Bennett is Bennett paying his Cable Broadband bill to Comcast. Now you people are libeling me claiming you somehow know I get paid by AT&T based on something you’ve heard. Now unless you got some facts to back that statement up, I’d suggest you retract that statement and STOP libeling me.
I'll say it to you people one last time, I have NEVER received money from any company other than my former employer CNET Networks and Fujitsu. I was Technical Director for CNET's ZDNet and I was a network engineer and consultant for Fujitsu.
Now it’s fairly obvious the Grannies were told and prepared to shout down my testimony as soon as I started speaking since they couldn’t have known who I was or what I was going to say. You people don’t even have any specific statements that you disagree with me on yet you’re a bunch of mindless attack dogs. Now at least have the decency to quote me correctly.
Marvin Ammori of Free Press likes to libel Richard Bennett as a Comcast shill when the only money flowing between Comcast and Bennett is Bennett paying his Cable Broadband bill to Comcast. Now you people are libeling me claiming you somehow know I get paid by AT&T based on something you’ve heard. Now unless you got some facts to back that statement up, I’d suggest you retract that statement and STOP libeling me.
I'll say it to you people one last time, I have NEVER received money from any company other than my former employer CNET Networks and Fujitsu. I was Technical Director for CNET's ZDNet and I was a network engineer and consultant for Fujitsu.
Now it’s fairly obvious the Grannies were told and prepared to shout down my testimony as soon as I started speaking since they couldn’t have known who I was or what I was going to say. You people don’t even have any specific statements that you disagree with me on yet you’re a bunch of mindless attack dogs. Now at least have the decency to quote me correctly.
George,
As someone moderately well-informed on the Net Neutrality issue, I attended the Stanford hearing to learn more. I found your testimony to be laughably pro-corporate and remarkably uninformed -- so did everyone sitting around me. I really shook my head at your assertion that sending "reset" packets around the network is a common and standard thing. We were all wondering who in the world had invited you to be on the panel -- maybe you could clear that up for us.
Of course, I just had to look you up when I got home, and found many others sharing my viewpoints. Some of the first links I found refer to you as an Ignorant Microsoft Shill...others laugh at your uninformed commentary... and still others take serious issue with your security "advice."
I hope the FCC Commissioners were as smart as the audience members sitting around me and won't take seriously anything you told them.
As someone moderately well-informed on the Net Neutrality issue, I attended the Stanford hearing to learn more. I found your testimony to be laughably pro-corporate and remarkably uninformed -- so did everyone sitting around me. I really shook my head at your assertion that sending "reset" packets around the network is a common and standard thing. We were all wondering who in the world had invited you to be on the panel -- maybe you could clear that up for us.
Of course, I just had to look you up when I got home, and found many others sharing my viewpoints. Some of the first links I found refer to you as an Ignorant Microsoft Shill...others laugh at your uninformed commentary... and still others take serious issue with your security "advice."
I hope the FCC Commissioners were as smart as the audience members sitting around me and won't take seriously anything you told them.
We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!
Get Involved
If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.
Publish
Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.
Topics
More
Search Indybay's Archives
Advanced Search
►
▼
IMC Network