top
Central Valley
Central Valley
Indybay
Indybay
Indybay
Regions
Indybay Regions North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area North Coast Central Valley North Bay East Bay South Bay San Francisco Peninsula Santa Cruz IMC - Independent Media Center for the Monterey Bay Area California United States International Americas Haiti Iraq Palestine Afghanistan
Topics
Newswire
Features
From the Open-Publishing Calendar
From the Open-Publishing Newswire
Indybay Feature

Wrap up of 5 days of protests against the abuse of circus animals in Fresno

by Dallas Blanchard
Fresno Voices For Animals activists ends 5 days of protests against the Ringling Brothers Circus.
banner10.jpg
Dozens of activists from throughout the Central Valley and the Bay area joined Fresno Voices for Animals in five days of raucus protests against Ringling Bros. Circus, a subsidiary of Feld Entertainment. Security officials from Feld, which bills itself as the world's largest live action family entertainment coglomerate, were kept busy working with Fresno PD in trying to limit activists contact with circus-goers. But despite record temperatures for the year, with the mercury hitting 109 on Saturday and Sunday, five arrests at the beginning of Thursday's shows, and repeated threats from Feld, arena officials, and Fresno police, activists persevered. They banged drums, displayed a twenty foot banner and numerous signs including a five foot tombstone listing animals that have died in Ringling's "care", took backstage photos of Ringling animal handlers with bullhooks, and handed out thousands of pieces of literature detailing the abuse of circus animals.
Activists stated that Feld circulated rumors suggesting that the activists were violence-prone and had trashed the premises during last year's protests. But two janitors said they quit their arena jobs when their bosses repeatedly sent them out into the heatwave to clean up after the protesters and found there was never any mess.
Many patrons of Ringling/Feld stopped to learn more from ativists about animal treatment in the circus, and many declared that this would be their last animal circus show. Prior to the Saturday show a group of approximately twelve children and their three adult chaperones talked matters over with the activists. One of the adults explained to the kids that the issue was like having your cat or dog caged up almost all of the time and then hitting the animal until it performed tricks. The adults then asked the children to vote on whether they wanted to go to the circus or go for pizza and a movie. The kids voted for the movie and proceeded to tear up their tickets and throw the pieces into the air.
Following the Saturday show, as circus-goers were leaving, activists projected onto a large screen video of elephant rampages, dehydrated and emaciated animals discovered inside of circus trailers, and graphic images of the pain inflicted on elephants by a Carson and Barnes circus animal trainer. Large numbers of patrons stopped to watch, apparently horrified at the scenes and asking for more information from activists.
In a strange twist on law enforcement, two different Fresno police officers were assigned to patrol the event each day. As the officers seemed to have been given little information from headquarters on the parameters for the protest, they took their cues from Feld and arena officials. [Fresno's Selland arena is operated by SMG corporation and private entities renting the building pay for police to patrol during events.] Each day protesters got a different version on the rightful areas in which to hold signs and leaflet, and officers regularly checked with SMG and Feld people for answers to legal questions about the protest. It was not until Sunday's shows that activists finally were provided with a Federal Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruling on a similar incident at the Cow Palace in San Francisco and discovered that their treatment actally fell considerbaly short of that required by the ruling.
Activists report that they will seek an ordinance from the city of Fresno banning all future animal circuses from the city.
§Video being shot of Fresno PD
by Dallas Blanchard
videoofcops.jpg
A couple of activists from San Jose are getting Fresno Police officers on video saying that people would be arrested for handling out flyers on a public sidewalk.
§Children listening to activists
by Dallas Blanchard
kidslistening.jpg
A group of children and their parents stop to listen to what animal rights activists have to say.
§Tickets in the Air
by Dallas Blanchard
kidstickets.jpg
The children who listened to what the activists had to say hold their tickets in the air just before they tore them up. They then went for pizza and a movie.
§watching Video
by Dallas Blanchard
watchingvideo.jpg
Here another group of children stop to watch a video about how the circus treats its animals
Add Your Comments

Comments (Hide Comments)
by Herbert Huncke
The idea that the Fresno police department will arrest people handing out flyers on a public sidewalk is very disturbing. Is there any plan to challenge this. Will the chief of police be called upon to comment on this? Is it police department policy? Is this legal?

by me
As I recall in Fresno they sued and won the right to protest in a shopping mall, so they should also be able to sue (and collect) in this case as well.
by william
Responding to "me" and to Hubert Huncke--

I was at all five days of protests. The police situation was ridiculous. As the article mentioned, when the police had questions about the "rights" of the protesters they called the arena people, and when the arena people had complaints about the protesters they basically told the police what to do. Each new shift of officers meant a new set of "guidelines" for us. On Thursday, they simply arrested people.

Fresno Voices for Animals is searching for legal representaion. We're not like Feld Inc.--no deep pockets. So if anyone has any ideas on legal help we'd love to find out.
by Cathy Lindeboom (sandcatt2003 [at] sbcglobal.net)
I spoke with Ellie, and not only do you all need to fill out police complaint forms, but you have clear grounds for a lawsuit. I was told a similar incident happened to Elfie (his videocamera confiscated) and he succesfully sued FPD. I'll call around, anyone who wants to talk to me, call me at the station or at home.

Cathy
by Herbert Huncke
And if you need a few bucks to support this lawsuit, let me/us know.
by mike robe
The individiuals arrested during Thursday's Ringling protests are being represented by a group of well known Fresno attorneys. We'll post a story in a few days.

Regarding financial help for legal defense, thanks Herbert Huncke and others. We are currently establishing a legal defense fund. Information regarding contributions, a fund-raiser, and other matters will be available very soon.

Thanks for your support, and thanks in the first place for being a voice for the animals.


We are 100% volunteer and depend on your participation to sustain our efforts!

Donate

$150.00 donated
in the past month

Get Involved

If you'd like to help with maintaining or developing the website, contact us.

Publish

Publish your stories and upcoming events on Indybay.

IMC Network