California bucks immigration enforcement trend

> California extends a hand to undocumented students:
>
>
> http://www.nctimes.com/articles/2008/06/07/news/sandiego/zeb1152eca772d1348825745f00669a90.txt


[image: NCTimes.com] [image: Californian.com] Last modified Saturday,
June 7, 2008 4:36 PM PDT


REGION: California bucks immigration enforcement trend

By EDWARD SIFUENTES - Staff Writer

While other states move away from giving illegal immigrant college students
state benefits, the California Legislature appears to be pushing to give
them more access to colleges and universities.

Last month, North Carolina's community college system said it would no
longer admit illegal immigrants.

But in California, where illegal immigrants are allowed to enroll in state
colleges, some lawmakers are backing a bill that would allow illegal
immigrants to qualify for state financial aid and fee waivers.

An estimated 65,000 illegal immigrants graduate from U.S. high schools each
year and could potentially attend college, according to a study by the Urban
Institute, a Washington-based economic and social policy research
organization.

Those students often are at the forefront of the nation's debate over
immigration reform.

Some see the students as a burden on the state's strained resources.

Others see them as victims of the nation's broken immigration system.

"These students are being severely impacted by inhumane immigration laws,
and I think our educational laws need to change to ensure that all our
students have equal access to education," said Arcela Nunez-Alvarez, who
heads the National Latino Research Institute at Cal State San Marcos.

Under a 2001 law, illegal immigrant students are given the same tuition
discount as other state residents who attend UC, CSU and community college
schools.

Late last month, the state Assembly approved Assembly Bill 2083 by
Assemblyman Fabian Nunez, D-Los Angeles. The bill would give illegal
immigrant students access to state grants, scholarships, work-study and loan
programs, which are now denied to them.

A similar bill ---- known as the California Dream Act, named after a federal
bill that would give illegal immigrant students legal status ---- was passed
by the Legislature last year and was vetoed by Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger.

This year's bill, which is now in the state Senate, was approved in the
Assembly largely along party lines, on a 46-31 vote. North County's
all-Republican delegation voted against the bill on the Assembly floor.

Assemblyman Martin Garrick, R-Carlsbad, said he doesn't want to give any
state benefits to illegal immigrants.

"If someone were to take two years off to serve their country and then
decide to come back to college and his seat is taken by someone who is not a
citizen of this country, that is not an acceptable scenario to me," Garrick
said.

The assemblyman said he would also support barring illegal immigrants from
attending state colleges.

Several North County legislators have repeatedly failed in their efforts to
roll back the state's in-state tuition policy for illegal immigrants. That's
largely due to the Democratic-dominated Legislature, which has effectively
blocked Republican efforts to curb school benefits.

In California, schools don't ask a student's immigration status when they
apply for admission. They are allowed to apply for lower in-state tuition
rates, but are not eligible for state and federal financial aid benefits.

On the other hand, some states are pushing even harder to bar illegal
immigrant students from entering their colleges and universities.

*A national debate*

The issue became a matter of debate recently in North Carolina. Last year,
the community college system in that state chose to allow illegal immigrants
into its 58 schools. Under a previous policy, the decision was left to
individual campuses.

The change was supported by Gov. Mike Easley, but it provoked heavy
criticism ---- especially from the leading candidates running to replace the
outgoing governor. That led the community college system to seek an opinion
from the state attorney general's office on whether the admissions policy
was legal under federal law.

Attorney General Roy Cooper's office recommended the community colleges drop
the lenient admissions policy, and suggested they follow stricter guidelines
under which illegal immigrants were not eligible for a public post-secondary
education.

Both Easley and the community college system asked Cooper's office to seek
formal guidance from federal authorities.

Federal immigration officials last month released a statement saying there
is no law prohibiting the state from educating illegal immigrants at public
colleges and universities.

Another state that is cracking down on illegal immigrant students is South
Carolina, where Gov. Mark Sanford signed a bill Wednesday that bans illegal
immigrants from attending public colleges.

William Gheen, who heads Americans for Legal Immigration, an anti-illegal
immigration group based in North Carolina, said he hopes other states follow
South Carolina's example.

"The momentum for immigration enforcement is clear in the states," Gheen
said.

The South Carolina law is one of several passed by states in recent years.
The other states include Arizona, Oklahoma, Georgia and Colorado.

Arizona's law, approved by voters through a ballot measure in 2006,
prohibits illegal immigrants from paying the less expensive in-state tuition
rates. To attend a state school, they must pay the heftier
out-of-state-fees.

*Remove the incentive*

Gheen said that a major reason why illegal immigrants come to the country is
to give their children access to U.S. schools.

"We must turn off all incentives for illegal aliens, and access to American
colleges is clearly an incentive for illegal alien families to come here,"
Gheen said.

In 1994, voters in California passed one of the harshest anti-illegal
immigration laws, Proposition 187, which would have barred illegal immigrant
children from attending all public schools. The law was ruled largely
unconstitutional.

Last year, Schwarzenegger vetoed the California Dream Act, saying that
extending benefits to illegal immigrant students would put further strains
on the state's budget.

Given the state's multibillion-dollar budget deficit this year, the governor
is likely to veto the bill again if it makes it to his desk.

However, some local Latino professors say not educating these students may
create problems down the line and waste their valuable talents.

Gheen said advocates for illegal immigrant rights are using children to
further their goals.

"I find it particularly distasteful that in their desperation they are using
children as pawns," Gheen said. "They are playing on Americans' sympathies
to get what they want."

Palomar College Professor John Valdez disagreed. He said he sees students'
disappointment every day.

"I have encountered students that are bright and talented, but who become
frustrated because they can't continue their education," Valdez said. "And
it's depriving the country of these bright and talented people."

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Contact staff writer Edward Sifuentes at (760) 740-3511 or
esifuentes [at] nctimes.com.